Kwantlen Polytechnic University KORA: Kwantlen Open Resource Access All Faculty Scholarship Faculty Scholarship 2015 Cooperative Learning Group Activities for College Courses Alice Macpherson Kwantlen Polytechnic University Follow this and additional works at: http://kora.kpu.ca/facultypub Part of the Curriculum and Instruction Commons, Educational Assessment, Evaluation, and Research Commons, and the Higher Education and Teaching Commons Original Publication Citation Macpherson, A. (1999, 2015) Cooperative Learning Group Activities for College Courses. Surrey, BC Canada: Kwantlen Polytechnic University. This Teaching Resource is brought to you for free and open access by the Faculty Scholarship at KORA: Kwantlen Open Resource Access. It has been accepted for inclusion in All Faculty Scholarship by an authorized administrator of KORA: Kwantlen Open Resource Access. For more information, please contact kora@kpu.ca. COOPERATIVE LEARNING GROUP ACTIVITIES FOR COLLEGE COURSES Written and compiled by Alice Macpherson, MA, PhD Kwantlen Polytechnic University 1999-2015 This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. Abstract Cooperative Learning Group Activities for College Courses Cooperative Learning Group Activities for College Courses is a compilation of cooperative learning activities suitable for use in college level courses. The book is composed of six major sections. The first section is a foreword on how to use this guide. Section two is a brief overview of the elements of cooperative learning and how they can be applied. The next two sections are organizational activities for instructors and preparatory activities for participants prior to using the fifth, main section, containing over 100 customizable activity structures for a variety of objectives and learning outcomes. It includes a template for developing cooperative learning activities, as well as sample group activities for:           climate setting, group function, accountability, knowledge and comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis and evaluation, interaction and practise, reflection, activities to complement projects, activities to acquire feedback, and  activities to end a course. The final section has questions for debriefing both group and idea processing. This material is intended to assist instructors to design and apply effective cooperative learning activities over a variety of disciplines. Keywords: Cooperative Learning, Collaborative Learning, Positive Interdependence, Individual Accountability, Groups Processing, Communications, Promotive Interaction, Group Development. Citation: Macpherson, A. (1999, 2015) Cooperative Learning Group Activities for College Courses. Surrey, BC Canada: Kwantlen Polytechnic University. ii COOPERATIVE LEARNING GROUP ACTIVITIES FOR COLLEGE COURSES – A GUIDE FOR INSTRUCTORS Table of Contents Abstract ................................................................................................................................................... ii Foreword ................................................................................................................................................ ix Elements of Cooperative Learning ................................................................................................ 1 Goal Structure Definitions..................................................................................................................... 2 Basic Elements of Cooperative Learning ............................................................................................. 3 Difference between Small Groups and Cooperative Learning .......................................................... 4 Why Use Cooperative Learning? .......................................................................................................... 5 Tuckman’s Team Development Model................................................................................................. 7 Stages of Team Development................................................................................................................. 8 What are the Types of Cooperative Learning Groups? ..................................................................... 9 What does Research on Cooperative Learning Say? ........................................................................ 11 How Do We Instruct Cooperative Team Skills? ............................................................................... 13 Organizational Activities – Instructor ......................................................................................... 15 Preparatory Activities – Participants........................................................................................... 16 Activity Structures ........................................................................................................................ 17 Template for Cooperative Learning Activities .................................................................................. 18 Group Activities for Climate Setting and Group Formation ..................................................... 21 Icebreaker – Find Someone Who ........................................................................................................ 22 Three Part, Four Step Interview ......................................................................................................... 23 Teambuilder – Treasure Hunt ............................................................................................................ 24 Develop Communication Guidelines .................................................................................................. 27 Develop and Share Personal Goals ..................................................................................................... 29 Form Support Groups.......................................................................................................................... 30 Trust Building ....................................................................................................................................... 31 Form Formal Groups ........................................................................................................................... 33 Goal Setting ........................................................................................................................................... 34 Group Processing ................................................................................................................................. 35 Share Experiences and Feelings .......................................................................................................... 36 Classbuilder – Wanted Poster ............................................................................................................. 37 iii Classbuilder – Matching Icons ............................................................................................................ 39 Group Closure ...................................................................................................................................... 41 Group Activities for Group Function .......................................................................................... 43 Constructive Communication Strategies ........................................................................................... 44 “I” Language ......................................................................................................................................... 45 Feedback Basics .................................................................................................................................... 47 Paraphrasing ......................................................................................................................................... 49 Active Listening I.................................................................................................................................. 50 Active Listening II ................................................................................................................................ 52 Active Listening Tape .......................................................................................................................... 54 Perception Checking ............................................................................................................................ 55 Quality Team Assessment .................................................................................................................... 58 Team Quality Chart ............................................................................................................................. 59 Negotiating Compromise ..................................................................................................................... 60 Activities to Promote Accountability ........................................................................................... 61 Numbered Heads Together.................................................................................................................. 62 Terror Cards ......................................................................................................................................... 63 Develop and Implement a Coaching Plan .......................................................................................... 64 Group Activities for Knowledge and Comprehension ................................................................ 67 Think-Pair-Share.................................................................................................................................. 68 Search-Pair-Share ................................................................................................................................ 69 Pair Read ............................................................................................................................................... 70 Jigsaw .................................................................................................................................................... 71 Nightmare Cards .................................................................................................................................. 74 Define Categories from Experiences .................................................................................................. 75 Flash Cards ........................................................................................................................................... 76 Visualization.......................................................................................................................................... 77 Follow a Process ................................................................................................................................... 78 Trace a Continuum............................................................................................................................... 79 Pair Review Form Completion............................................................................................................ 80 Discussion – Small Group – Knowledge ............................................................................................. 81 Discussion – Small Group – Comprehension ..................................................................................... 82 Discussion – Small Group – Factors to be Considered ..................................................................... 83 Pair Review Note Taking ..................................................................................................................... 84 iv Formulate a Report .............................................................................................................................. 85 Prepare Reports .................................................................................................................................... 86 Group Activities for Application .................................................................................................. 87 Read Maps / Charts .............................................................................................................................. 88 Prepare a Block Diagram .................................................................................................................... 89 Create a Flow Chart ............................................................................................................................. 90 Personal Planning ................................................................................................................................. 91 Solve Problems ...................................................................................................................................... 92 Create a Classification Matrix ............................................................................................................ 93 Propose Situations ................................................................................................................................ 94 Develop Incidents ................................................................................................................................. 95 Develop Timelines................................................................................................................................. 96 Create Scenarios ................................................................................................................................... 97 Operate Equipment (I) ......................................................................................................................... 98 Discussion – Small Group – Application .......................................................................................... 100 Group Activities for Analysis ..................................................................................................... 101 Brainstorm Plus .................................................................................................................................. 102 Pass a Problem .................................................................................................................................... 103 Compare Systems ............................................................................................................................... 105 Differentiate Situations ...................................................................................................................... 106 Classify ................................................................................................................................................ 107 Analyze Audiotape.............................................................................................................................. 108 Analyze Video ..................................................................................................................................... 109 Develop a Personal Response ............................................................................................................ 110 Present Opinions................................................................................................................................. 111 Operate Equipment (II) ..................................................................................................................... 112 Discussion – Small Group – Analysis ............................................................................................... 113 Analyze Ways to Assist ...................................................................................................................... 114 Develop a Graphic Representation ................................................................................................... 115 Graph a Change .................................................................................................................................. 116 Group Activities for Synthesis and Evaluation ......................................................................... 119 Assess and Recommend ..................................................................................................................... 120 Compare Situations ............................................................................................................................ 122 Compare Supports and Limits .......................................................................................................... 123 v Compare Systems ............................................................................................................................... 124 Compare Processes ............................................................................................................................. 125 Conduct an Audit ............................................................................................................................... 126 Develop a Form ................................................................................................................................... 127 Develop a Case Study ......................................................................................................................... 128 Link Characteristics ........................................................................................................................... 129 Expand on Functions .......................................................................................................................... 130 Develop an Analogy ............................................................................................................................ 131 Identify Benefits.................................................................................................................................. 132 Identify Issues ..................................................................................................................................... 133 Pair Contrast for Differences ............................................................................................................ 134 Analyze Reports .................................................................................................................................. 135 Analyze Case Studies .......................................................................................................................... 136 Develop Strategies using Case Studies.............................................................................................. 137 Prioritize Situations............................................................................................................................ 138 List / Refer / Clarify ........................................................................................................................... 139 Structured Academic Controversy ................................................................................................... 140 Discussion – Small Group – Synthesis .............................................................................................. 141 Discussion – Small Group – Evaluation ........................................................................................... 142 Group Activities for Interaction and Practise ........................................................................... 143 Dialogue ............................................................................................................................................... 144 Interact with a Guest Speaker ........................................................................................................... 145 Interactive Practise ............................................................................................................................ 146 Interactive Practise – Call Taking .................................................................................................... 148 Group Activities for Reflection .................................................................................................. 151 Reflective Practise – Observation ..................................................................................................... 152 Reflective Practise – Questions or Situations .................................................................................. 154 Reflective Practise – Response to Change ........................................................................................ 155 Reflective Practise – Identify Personal Bias .................................................................................... 156 Reflective Practise – Effect of Assumptions .................................................................................... 157 Group Activities to Complement Projects ................................................................................. 158 Set Criteria – Project or Exercise ..................................................................................................... 159 Report on Field Trips ......................................................................................................................... 161 Use a Model for Assessment .............................................................................................................. 162 vi Use Resource Materials...................................................................................................................... 163 Research Information ........................................................................................................................ 164 Summarize........................................................................................................................................... 165 Make Referrals ................................................................................................................................... 166 Review an Assignment ....................................................................................................................... 167 Develop Interview Questions ............................................................................................................. 168 Develop a Plan .................................................................................................................................... 170 Exercise a Plan .................................................................................................................................... 171 Make a Presentation ........................................................................................................................... 172 Group Activities to Acquire Feedback....................................................................................... 175 Identify Key Points ............................................................................................................................. 176 Classroom Research ........................................................................................................................... 177 One Minute Paper .............................................................................................................................. 178 Summarize........................................................................................................................................... 179 RSQC2 ................................................................................................................................................. 180 Group Activities to End a Course .............................................................................................. 181 Write Course Questions ..................................................................................................................... 182 Write a Legacy Letter ........................................................................................................................ 183 Exchange Success Tips ....................................................................................................................... 184 Debriefing for Group Processing .............................................................................................. 185 Debriefing for Idea Processing.................................................................................................. 188 List of References ....................................................................................................................... 190 Cooperative Learning Internet Based Resources ..................................................................... 192 Index ........................................................................................................................................... 193 vii Foreword How to Use this Guide The purpose of this guide is to support instructors in enabling learners to effectively assimilate and apply curriculum material to meet the learning objectives. It is intended for the instructor who has experience and skill in conducting group learning and who is a current content expert in the subject matter. The first chapter includes an introduction to Cooperative Learning but should not be considered in depth. Individual training and study is also recommended to supplement this book. A commitment to lifelong learning and change is important because of the fluid nature of information and knowledge. The instructor needs to acquire and include subject matter content and additional support materials, reports, resources and information when using these structures. Facilitation Principles The following are some of the principles that should be considered throughout the use of these activities. Continued Planning and Preparation Planning and preparation are an essential part of instruction. The time required to plan and prepare should not be underestimated, particularly the time it takes for the material to be delivered. As an instructor delivering any content, we should be prepared to acquire and include support materials, worksheets, reports, resources, and other pertinent information. A commitment to lifelong learning and change is important because of the fluid nature of information and knowledge. The learning activities in this guide are set out in template form so that they can be customized to suit a particular course or group according to participants’ needs. As you customize the activity to your topic and your group, develop questions that will have a range of answers and will also require students to analyze and evaluate. Equal Importance of Process and Content Process and content are equally important. The instructor should attend to group and team dynamics, issues arising, and individual needs that may require attention. Participants need to feel they have been heard when they express issues of concern. Concurrently, the group and instructor need to modify their expectations or requirements as appropriate to the level of understanding and interaction of the group. Balance within the Process Attention to the process also means attention to the participants who dominate the group, and others who remain silent. The instructor should strive for balance in the level of participation among learners, encouraging quieter members to speak and politely telling more dominant members to give everyone a chance to speak. Group guidelines for communication that are set by the group are an important element of this. ix Encourage Participation Experiential learning is one of the foundations of adult education. It has been proven to be a more effective method of mastering content than hearing a lecture, seeing a demonstration, or participating in a large discussion. It is suggested that there be a balance of small group and team activities, triads, pairs, and whole group work. Instructors should note that there will be times when a short lecture may be necessary. Simulations through lab work and access to a reality environment need to be built into the curriculum. Acknowledge Prior Learning Participants come to courses with different knowledge, skills and needs. These differences should be acknowledged at the outset. The learning activities should facilitate ways for group members to learn from each other, as well as to learn from the instructor and the content. A good process rule is to move participants around so they work in small groups with different people. Mixing participants is also a good strategy for breaking up groups that may be stuck (too vocal or quiet) and can be the basis for some kinds of heterogeneity. Flexible Times The instructor must be flexible in adapting time frames and content to the needs of the group. An activity that is given a suggested time frame of 30 minutes may take over an hour if the group finds the subject thought-provoking enough to discuss in more depth. The instructor must make some choices about time and adjust the agenda as necessary. At times the instructor should consult with the group in deciding how to proceed. Make Time for Issues There will be occasions when the group identifies a question or content area that seems important enough to address, explore or research in more detail. When this occurs, the instructor must try to address this need. One strategy is to gain cooperation from the group and agreement that this information is a priority. Another strategy is to identify the issue as significant and agree to return to it at a later time. Instructor Responsibility The instructor must however, maintain a certain degree of control in managing and guiding the group so that the learning outcomes are achieved. This means balancing the individual needs of group members with the overall structure and content of the curriculum and the overall needs of the group. How to Plan Activities Lessons are laid out in such a way that they may be changed and adapted to suit the participant group. The Instructional Strategies section gives suggested time frames for each activity. However, these times will vary, depending on the skill level, experiences, size, and composition of the group. x Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities ELEMENTS OF COOPERATIVE LEARNING When is Cooperation Desirable? “Whenever problem solving is desired, whenever divergent thinking or creativity is desired, whenever quality of performance is expected, whenever the task is complex, when the learning goals are highly important, and when the social development of learners is one of the major instructional goals... When an instructor wishes to promote positive interaction among learners, a facilitative learning climate, a wide range of cognitive and affective outcomes, and positive relations between themselves and the learners…” From Learning Together and Alone, David W. Johnson, Roger T. Johnson What is Cooperative Learning? Cooperative Learning is part of a group of teaching/learning techniques where students interact with each other to acquire and practise the elements of a subject matter and to meet common learning goals. It is much more than just putting students into groups and hoping for the best. Cooperative Learning is a very formal way of structuring activities in a learning environment that includes specific elements intended to increase the potential for rich and deep learning by the participants. Cooperative Learning models include the following basic principles:  Group tasks are designed to be suitable for group work.  Positive interdependence is built in – cooperation is necessary for students to succeed.  Attention and class time are given to interpersonal/cooperative skill building.  Participants learn together in small (2-5 member) groups.  Students are individually accountable for learning and participation.  The instructor’s role changes from being the "sage on the stage" to the "guide on the side." Cooperative Learning is about moving from rote learning to learning how to think critically and in changing circumstances. The consistent use of these principles in an organized way is at the heart of Cooperative Learning. 1 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Goal Structure Definitions Cooperation: We Sink or Swim Together Lessons are structured so that learners work together to maximize their own and each other’s learning. Learners work together to achieve shared goals. All members of the group strive for all group members’ success. Work in small groups. Groups are heterogeneous. Joint success is celebrated. Evaluated by matching performance with clear criteria, set in advance. Competition: I Swim, You Sink; I Sink, You Swim Instructors structure lessons so that learners compete with each other to achieve a goal only a few can attain. Learners work alone. They strive to be better than the rest of the group. What benefits self, deprives others. Own success and others’ failure is celebrated. Rewards are limited. Graded on a curve or ranked from “best” to “worst”. Individualistic: We are Each in this Alone Learners work by themselves to accomplish learning goals unrelated to those of other learners. Learners work alone. Strive for their own success. What benefits self does not affect others. Own success is celebrated. Rewards are viewed as unlimited Evaluated by comparing performance to pre-set criteria. Adapted from Active Learning: Cooperation in the College Classroom (1991), Johnson, Johnson, and Smith 2 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Basic Elements of Cooperative Learning David W. Johnson, Roger T. Johnson, Edythe, J. Holubec and others identify five basic elements of cooperative learning. Positive Interdependence Interaction through Activity Learners help, assist, encourage, and support each others’ efforts to learn. Individual Accountability The performance of each individual learner is assessed and the results given back to the group and the individual. Group Processing Interaction through Reflection At the end of their working period the groups process their functioning by answering two questions: what did each member do that was helpful for the group? and what can each member do to make the group work better? Skilled Interpersonal Communication Skilled communication is necessary for effective group functioning. Learners must have, and use, the needed leadership, decision making, trust-building, effective communication, and conflictmanagement skills. Face-to-Face Promotive Interactions Interdependence through Structure Learners believe that they are linked together; they cannot succeed unless the other members of the group succeed (and vice versa). They “sink or swim together.” Other ways to identify Elements of Cooperative Learning Spencer Kagen in Cooperative Learning, Resources for Teachers (1994) identify the needed elements as: Positive Interdependence, Individual Accountability, Equal Participation, and Simultaneous Interaction. 3 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Difference between Small Groups and Cooperative Learning Traditional Small Groups In traditional small groups, the instructor merely tells class participants to form groups to complete a class assignment. There is no structured interdependence, no individual accountability, and communication skills are either assumed or ignored. Sometimes the group or the instructor may appoint a single leader. The emphasis is on the task to be performed and there is no process for group processing. In the end, each person is responsible only for themselves. Often the instructor sets the groups and then leaves them to work on their own until the time allotted to the task is completed. Cooperative Learning Teams In cooperative learning teams positive interdependence is structured into the group task activities and members are responsible for each other’s success. Individual accountability is an expected outcome. Communication skills are identified, directly taught, and expected to be used by all group members. There are designated roles with shared leadership assigned and monitored by the group and the instructor. The group regularly processes how they are working together and adjusts their personal and group behaviours accordingly. Both task and maintenance roles and outcomes are emphasized. The instructor observes and intervenes if necessary to ensure that the process is followed. Working In Groups Not everyone likes interdependent group work, which requires cooperation with others to accomplish a task. Part of functioning in a group is to have a common vision, common goals, and a common mission even though you may work independently on a project; and to understand that you and your work represent the group. Develop group Outcomes, Objectives and Guidelines (or mission statement, goals and principles – terminology can change) with your learners. These are based on your official course, but give the participants a chance to clarify the intended end product, direction and means of interaction within the course. This needs to include discussions around how each member of the “group” or class will support those intentions. Then, although the participants may work alone at some times and in groups at others, they start to understand that they are responsible to a bigger “collective”. We will always be a part of a group, but we will not necessarily always work in groups. Team work is a necessary component because it is reflective of how advances are being made in business, science, education, etc. If our learners do not know how to work in groups, and how to function as a group member, we have not adequately prepared them for future work situations. Learners have a need to be successful. If they question grades and take grades seriously it is as much for their own personal identity as successful, competent persons, as it is for their realization how this will reflect on them later in the “real” world. 4 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Why Use Cooperative Learning? As instructors of adults prepare their curriculum materials they must make plans and decisions about which teaching strategies they will apply in what circumstances. Instructors may structure lessons so that: 1. Learners are in a win-lose struggle to see who is best. Learners are competing with each other. 2. Learners learn on their own, individually, without interacting with other learners. 3. Learners work in pairs or small groups to help each other master the assigned material. Essential instructional skills all instructors need to know are when and how to structure learners’ learning goals competitively, individualistically and cooperatively. Reasons to Use Cooperative Learning 1. Adults often manage conflicts destructively. We tend to behave as we have been taught. A highly individualistic and competitive environment may lead to an inability to get along or manage conflicts constructively. 2. Industry requires people who can work cooperatively in teams. The Conference Board of Canada has said that learners need academic skills, personal skills and cooperative or teamwork skills. Schools and colleges generally do a good job of the academic skills but often neglect the personal and teamwork skills because they see them as the responsibility of the home. With family life changing, many learners do not develop these skills at home. 3. Researchers have found that 90 to 95% of the people who lose their jobs do so because they cannot get along with other people on the job. Only 5 or 10 percent (depending on which studies you read) of people lose their jobs because they cannot do the work. Cooperative learning helps people learn social skills and therefore increases the chances that they will be able to keep the jobs for which we are training them. 4. Learners bring with them their own negative attitudes and prejudices. Population diversity is becoming more the norm than the exception in many places. When there is a mix of learners in the same class there is the potential to diminish negative attitudes and to develop positive ones depending how interaction is structured. Cooperative learning structures can be used to develop constructive and supportive peer relationships. How do Cooperative Teams Work? A team can occur anytime there are two or more people working towards a common goal or objective. After a team gets bigger than four there is a tendency to form sub-teams who may all be working towards the same goal but not necessarily in communication with the other sub-team. An ideal size for a cooperative team is four members per group. When you have four in a group, you can have pairs working together at times and four working together at other times. There is a possibility of six pair combinations. Various constraints will affect the size of the group. For a team to work effectively it is important to recognize that there are steps that will happen and that the team task and interpersonal behaviours will change over time. A team or group 5 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities develops a culture of traits and patterns as they progress. Dr. Bruce Tuckman developed a model of how teams progress and exhibit behaviours around both the task being done and the interpersonal interactions. Stage 1: Forming This is the time of organization and orientation to tasks. The task(s) and information about them will be identified. The question to be answered is “What is the task of this group and how will I be able to contribute to that task?” In the behaviour area, the members will develop group guidelines, either by consensus or by informal testing of behaviours. Some members will look to others to either lead or follow. The question to be answered is “What kind of behaviour is acceptable in this group and how am I to behave?” Stage 2: Storming Here there are individual emotional responses to the group. The demands of the task will trigger part of this response and the more difficult the task appears in relation to individual’s selfperceived abilities, the greater the potential for a “storm”. The question to be answered is “Am I emotionally ready to deal with this task?” Varied understandings of task and roles are expressed or become apparent. Differences between members may be expressed in a hostile manner and members may wonder if they want to be part of the group. They think, “Do I really want to work with these people?” Stage 3: Norming Now communication is opening up and developing. Information is being exchanged and ideas and opinions are shared. The focus is on the task and members are answering the question, “What do I have that will help us accomplish this task?” Workable guidelines are established. On the behavioural side, the individuals are becoming a group. There is a sense of harmony and people are looking at “How can I help contribute to group unity?” Stage 4: Performing Everyone is focused on constructive action directed towards successful completion of the task. The interpersonal and task behaviours with shared understandings start to merge and functionality is the main idea. Problem solving will be primarily directed to the work and the product. Last Stage: Adjourning When teams have completed their tasks, they wrap up, and then go on to other teams in other places. It is important for the team to take the time to look at its process one last time. “What went well?” “What could we do better in another situation?” so that the loose ends are wrapped up on the task. The conclusion of the interpersonal behaviours includes a chance to say thank you and good-bye to the team members. This can range from an imaginary gift to each person all the way to various celebrations and even plans to meet again at a later date. Closure is a final essential part of the team process. The next two pages include descriptions of the stages and a variety of questions that may come up for each team on its journey. 6 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Tuckman’s Team Development Model achieving effective and satisfying results members find solutions to problems using appropriate controls Performing Task Behaviours members agree about roles and processes for problem solving members work collaboratively members care about each other group establishes a unique identity Norming identifying power and control issues gaining skills in communication identifying resources decisions are made through negotiation and consensus building Interpersonal Behaviours Storming establishing base level expectations identifying similarities agreeing on common goals Forming expressing differences of ideas, feelings and opinions reacting to leadership members independent/ counterdependent Remember making contact/bonding developing trust members are dependent   Each step builds on the previous one Each step prepares for the performing stage  Attempting to skip any step affects performing negatively With every new challenge, the process repeats  7 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Stages of Team Development Stage 1 “Forming” Stage 2 “Storming” Stage 3 “Norming” Stage 4 “Performing” individuals are not clear on what they’re supposed to do the mission isn’t owned by the group wondering where we are going no trust yet high learning no group history; unfamiliar with members norms of the team are not established people check one another out people are not committed to the team roles and responsibilities are articulated agendas are displayed problem solving doesn’t work well people want to modify the team’s mission trying new ideas splinter groups form people set boundaries anxiety abounds people push for position and power competition is high cliques drive the team little team spirit lots of personal attacks level of participation by members is at its highest (for some) and its lowest (for some) success occurs team has all the resources for doing the job appreciation and trust build purpose is well-defined feedback is high, well-received, and objective team confidence is high leader(s) reinforce team behaviours members self-reinforce team norms hidden agendas become open team is creative more individual motivation team gains commitment from all members on directions and goals team members feel very motivated individuals defer to team needs no surprises little waste-very efficient team operations team members have objective outlooks individuals take pleasure in the success of the team-big wins “we” versus “I” orientation high pride in the team high openness and support high empathy high trust in everyone superior team performance OK to risk confrontation Action Steps “Forming” to “Storming” Action Steps “Storming” to “Norming” Action Steps “Norming” to Performing” set a mission set goals identify how communication will occur establish roles needed by the group recognize need to move out of “forming” stage identify the team, its tools and resources leader(s) need to give direction identify ways to build trust (not demand it) define a reward structure take some risks bring group together to work on common tasks assert individual power decide completely to be on the teams leader(s) must ask for and expect results team members should actively support and reinforce team behaviour, facilitate the group for wins, create positive environment recognize and publicize team wins agree on individuals’ roles and responsibilities buy into objectives and activities listen actively to each other set and take team time together have the vision “we can succeed!” request and accept feedback build trust by honouring commitments and being trustworthy maintain positive traditions praise and support each other self-evaluate without fuss recognize and reinforce “synergy” team behaviour share leadership role in team based on who does what the best provide opportunities for learning share rewards for successes communicate clearly all the time share responsibility delegate freely within team commit time to the team keep raising the bar for new and higher goals be selective of new team members; train to maintain the team spirit (this will take you back to the beginning but movement to performing will be quicker) adapted from the Facilitator Development Workshop participant guide by CTT (1991) BC 8 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities What are the Types of Cooperative Learning Groups? There are three basic types of cooperative learning groups – base groups, formal cooperative learning groups and informal cooperative learning groups. Base or Home Groups Base groups are long-term cooperative learning groups with stable membership. Learners are chosen for base groups in a manner that will guarantee a good mix of academic levels in the group. These groups are set up to so that members provide support to each other so that all can succeed academically. For example, they may pick up handouts for each other if one of the group members is absent, and they will coach each other to prepare for individual tests. The use of base groups tends to personalize the classroom, improve attendance and also improve the quality and quantity of learning. If you have large numbers of learners in your classes, you should consider using base groups. Base groups should be set up so that they can remain together for at least a term and longer if possible. The more learners you have in a class and the more complex the subject matter, the more important it is to have base groups organized. The members should be compatible and supportive. Formal Cooperative Learning Groups These groups may last from several minutes to several class sessions to complete a specific task or assignment (such as doing a set of problems, completing a unit of work, writing a report, conducting an experiment, or reading and comprehending a story, play, chapter or book). The members are carefully chosen for hetrogenicity to maximize learning and minimize ‘group think’. Informal Cooperative Learning Groups These groups are temporary, ad hoc groups that last for a few minutes, one discussion or class period. The members are often chosen randomly and will rotate on a regular basis. Their purposes are to focus learner attention on the material to be learned, create an expectation set and mood conducive to learning, as well as help organize in advance the material to be covered in a class session. They can ensure that learners cognitively process the material being taught and provide closure to an instructional session. They may be used at any time but they are especially useful during a lecture or direct reading. The length of time that most college learners can attend to a lecture before they begin to drift away is around 20 to 25 minutes. These groups help break up the lecture and allow learners to process the content as they take part in class. Bookend Process: By breaking up the lecture into several mini-lectures and having learners process the material in cooperative learning groups, you do decrease the amount of lecture time, but you will enhance what is learned and build relationships among the learners in your class. When we are instructing we need to remember all the different learning styles and not go to either extreme and completely eliminate lecture or to give up on group work. 9 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Placing Learners into Cooperative Learning Groups Group Sizes The ideal size for cooperative learning groups according to most experts in the field is four learners per group. When you have four in a group, you can have pairs working together at times and four working together at other times. There are six different pair combinations possible in groups of four. There are many ways an instructor can place learners into groups. The following are a few ways this can be done: 1. Instructor Assigned Groups The instructor can assign learners to groups to ensure that the groups are heterogeneous. The real advantage to forming groups in this manner is that instructors can see to it that groups are heterogeneous in terms of academic ability, ethnic background, gender, and any other factors that they feel are important. The instructor tries to make sure that best friends and worst enemies are not in the same groups. If they are, communication patterns in the group are not as effective. 2. Randomly Assigned Groups The instructor can simply have learners number off, placing all the ones in one group, etc. 3. Social Integration Groups The instructor can ask learners to privately name learners they would like to work with and any they would not like to work with in groups, and use this information to construct groups. 4. Subject-Matter Related Groups If a group of learners are interested in a particular topic, they could be assigned to the same group to research and present the topic to the rest of the class. 5. Geographic Groups Particularly useful for formal or base groups, this allows participants who live near each other to have a greater ease in meeting. 6. Self-Selected Groups The instructor can simply ask learners to form their own groups – “Find three other people to work with on this project.” This can work well for short-term groups but can be counter productive if participants always end up in the same groupings. Most Effective Groups The most effective groups are usually the instructor assigned groups because they are more likely to be heterogeneous. Random groups and the others are very useful for short-term assignments, projects, but should not be used all the time or learners miss out on a lot of the advantages of working with heterogeneous groups. 10 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities What does Research on Cooperative Learning Say? Cooperative learning is supported by one of the strongest research traditions in education, with many hundreds of studies conducted across a wide range of subject areas and age groups (for reviews, see Bossert, 1988-1989; Cohen, 1994; Johnson & Johnson, 1989; Sharan, 1980; Slavin, 1995). This large body of research suggests that student to student collaboration conducted in a manner consistent with cooperative learning principles produces superior results on a host of variables, including achievement, thinking skills, interethnic relations, liking for school, and selfesteem. The general results of a (very) few of these studies are as follows: 1. Academic Achievement In experimental-control comparison studies of the achievement effects of cooperative learning, most found significantly greater achievement in cooperative than in control classes. Group goals and individual accountability had to be present for these academic gains to be present. Research on behaviours within groups that contribute to learning gains has found that learners who provide and receive elaborated explanations are those who gain the most from the activities. (Slavin, 1990) Learners in cooperative learning classrooms liked the subject areas more than other learners. They also had developed peer norms in favour of doing well academically. Critical thinking is stimulated and students clarify ideas through discussion and debate (Johnson 1973, 1974a) The level of discussion and debate within groups of three or more and between pairs is substantially greater than when an entire class participates in a teacher led discussion. Students receive immediate feedback or questions about their ideas and formulate responses without having to wait for long intervals to participate in the discussion (Peterson & Swing 1985). Using cooperative learning, students are continuously discussing, debating and clarifying their understanding of the concepts and materials being considered during the class. They are constructing their own knowledge base. The emphasis is on understanding the material as evidenced by the student's ability to explain ideas to their peers. This leads to a sense of content mastery versus a passive acceptance of information from an outside expert. This further promotes a sense of helplessness and reliance upon others to attain concepts. (Gentile, 1997) 2. Skilled Communication Researchers found that learners involved in cooperative learning activities developed skills for interpersonal communications more readily than learners who were in other classroom settings did. They were more considerate of others feelings, worked in cross-cultural situations more easily, liked their classmates and liked their teachers more than other learners. Researchers found that they developed friends from other cultures and kept these friends outside of class. They had positive expectations toward future interactions. They had more accurate understanding of others’ perspectives. In conflict situations, they were more able to negotiate and solve conflicts in a win-win manner. Brufee(1993) researched the concept of learning taking place when individuals move from the society which they are familiar with to the society which they wish to join by learning the vocabulary, language structure, and customs unique to that society. Working collaboratively is an 11 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities ideal way to facilitate the acquisition of language and to practise the customs of debate and discussion which occur in any particular academic field. Interacting collaboratively with the instructor in and out of class also facilitates the reaculturation process defined by Brufee. Social interaction skills are developed with cooperative learning strategies. A major component of cooperative learning elaborated by Johnson, Johnson and Holubec (1984) includes training students in the social skills needed to work collaboratively. Students do not come by these skills naturally. Quite the contrary, in our society and current educational framework competition is valued over cooperation. By asking group members to identify what behaviors help them work together and by asking individuals to reflect on their contribution to the group's success or failure, students are made aware of the need for healthy, positive, helping interactions when they work in groups (Cohen & Cohen 1991). Developing ways to manage conflict before conflict arises is an important part of this process. 3. Psychological Health Learners who were in classrooms with a significant amount of cooperative learning were psychologically healthier than learners who were not. They had higher self-esteem. Learners In cooperative learning classes have more positive feelings about themselves than do learners in traditional classes. Slavin (1990) also documented the findings that these learners had feelings of individual control over their own fate in school, their time on task was higher and their cooperativeness and altruism were higher as well. 12 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities How Do We Instruct Cooperative Team Skills? The instructor needs to clearly define the team function skills that you want to work on as described by learning outcomes and goals. Help learners see the need for the skill    Displaying concrete evidence that it is considered important Communicating information on benefits Validating competence in skill through suitable rewards Ensure learners understand what the skill is   Aiding them to generate specific phrases and behaviours Demonstrating, modeling and role playing appropriate behaviour  KIS (KEEP IT SIMPLE) Set up practise situations with real content     Assigning specific roles to ensure practise Indicating that skills will be counted (valued) Having fun to encourage skill use Keeping it up Ensure that learners process their use of the skills     Providing regular time for digesting and debriefing Using procedures for the group to assess – particularly observers Using positive feedback techniques, three things done well and one to do better Develop a group process to manage conflict Ensure practise continues to bring about integration Stages of skill development: 1. Awareness the skill is needed 2. Comprehension of what the skill is 3. Awkward feelings in application of skill 4. Mechanical use of skill 5. Automatic use of skill 13 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities ORGANIZATIONAL ACTIVITIES – INSTRUCTOR To maximize the potential for successful group activities the instructor needs to be fully prepared. The following are some of the activities that may need to be done before the group activity.               Ensure that interaction through activity, interdependence, individual accountability, interpersonal communication and interaction through reflection are built into the activity in a positive and promotive way and present in all structures and activities. Facilitate the setting of group guidelines for communication. Form heterogeneous groups of participants that match the learning objectives. Negotiate project groups with other instructors in similar areas. Structure suitable activities for the learning objectives. Identify suitable readings for activities. Monitor group activities. Negotiate with other instructors to allow for group projects that cover more than one subject area. Encourage participation – through structures, assignment of roles, coaching, etc. Arrange space to enable interaction through activity. Coach participants in positive interpersonal communications skills. Identify ways to promote positive interdependence through structures and activities. Require individual accountability in all activities through demonstrations, tests and documentation. Analyze group process with participants as well as group product using interaction through reflection. 15 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities PREPARATORY ACTIVITIES – PARTICIPANTS These are some of the activities that individual participants may be assigned to do before working in groups.    Commit to the concept of working with others. Participate in setting group guidelines for communication. Pre-read written materials using set questions to gather information.  Listen to an audiotape focusing on particular aspects.          Watch a videotape focusing on particular aspects. Prepare an extract from an article or chapter. Research specific aspects of a topic. Complete an inventory or survey. Prepare a presentation on a topic. Bring in news clippings on current subjects. Locate general information on the Internet. Write a one page description of a situation from personal experience. Keep a personal journal that relates to the subject. 16 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities ACTIVITY STRUCTURES The activities in this book follow a single framework which is detailed on the next page. In places where the activity can most easily be tailored to various subjects, there will the signal to given. It will be followed by {for instance: an example that might be used}. This is intended to help the instructor connect the activity with their own content area. The example in each case is suggestion only and not meant to be prescriptive. Each instructor needs to pick out and adapt these structures to their own course content and learner group. By using observations of groups and their process and progress it is possible to identify a hierarchy of abilities similar to Bloom's taxonomy by asking the following questions about the students: Do they know the basics – definitions, formulas, vocabulary, rules, and procedures needed to analyze and solve problems? Can they apply their knowledge to similar problems or questions? Are they able to extend their reasoning and analysis to new situations or problems? Can they create their own problem statements or questions based upon the underlying concepts being studied? Can they explain their reasoning in writing or verbally to their peers? By asking each of these questions one can identify the stage of development the student has reached and make recommendations as to what material and group activities might be applied to help them understand, apply and integrate the concepts more effectively. 17 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Template for Cooperative Learning Activities Purpose: What is the activity intended to do for the participants? Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment # min Provide information Guide activity Work interactively on Objective group, equipment 10 min Complete accountability Debrief activity Achieve content objective Discuss aids to process Whole group Activity – name of the activity Organizer: A statement about how the activity bridges to the content. Objective: A clear objective that can be achieved by the end of the activity. Pre Assessment: Can the learner already accomplish this skill? Time: How many minutes the activity will take. This will vary with the groups. Techniques / Equipment: All equipment and materials that will be needed. All instructor actions. Monitor and support participation and the exchange of ideas. Process:  Type and size of the groups Steps in the activity   Group Success / Assessment: objective and how it was reached. Accountability: the process. Everyone in the group has to be able to explain the How each person will be individually accountable for their part of Debrief: The group processes for how the activity went for each of them and how others helped them in their group. Summary: The instructor’s statement that wraps up the process. 18 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Purpose: Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities min min Organizer: Objective: Pre Assessment: Time: Techniques / Equipment: Process:     Group Success / Assessment: Accountability: Debrief: Summary: 19 Techniques / Equipment Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities GROUP ACTIVITIES FOR CLIMATE SETTING AND GROUP FORMATION The formation of the learning environment and how groups are created lay the foundation for all other group work in any class. The following activities are specifically targeted to enhance the formation of support and work groups as well as the communications process between group members. They are a critical part to setting a climate in the group that supports interaction. It is recommended that a selection of these activities be done with any large group or class before the content specific small group activities are started. Use Icebreakers, Teambuilders, and Classbuilders to reinforce the group atmosphere. There are many more than are shown here but these will provide a framework for building your own on a cooperative learning model. Learn Names People in a learning community know and use each other’s first names. It is important to monitor cooperative learning teams closely, so that you get to know students better and can interact with them more informally than you would in a whole-class setting. Any activity that makes the process of learning names and something about the members of the group will help everyone. Name tags or tents work well in very large classes. In smaller classes (up to 30 students) you can use the Name Game. Using the whole group, each student says their first name, the names of all students who came before them, and then their first name again. Develop Class Guidelines This is a set of agreed upon guidelines for communication and ways of interacting developed by participants to encourage skilled communication and provide a framework for managing conflict. The rules that come up are often identical to rules that you might have chosen, such as “Come to class prepared”, “Be willing to participate” or “Criticize ideas rather than individuals.” However, when the group develops them then there is deeper ownership and more probability that they will be used. 21 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Icebreaker – Find Someone Who Purpose: To encourage initial interaction with a group. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Provide initial information Guide activity Find Someone Who Identify differences Pairs or triads 10 min Ask for Introductions Debrief activity Introduce other person to group Discuss what was surprising Whole group Activity – Icebreaker – Find Someone Who Organizer: Since we will be working together we need to get to know each other. Objective: Find someone who has something in common with yourself. Identify something that is different between you and another person. Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: Personal experience. Flipchart, and coloured pens Individually seek out at least one other person who: “Does the same kinds of physical activities.”  Identify what you have in common.  Identify differences that you have. Group Success: Everyone in the group has to be able to explain the commonalities and differences. Accountability: Debrief: Introduce the other person to the rest of the group. What did you learn that was surprising? 22 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Three Part, Four Step Interview Purpose: skills. To encourage initial interaction with a group while focusing on communication Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Provide initial information (describe interview process – name, background, goals, other) Guide activity Interview one person in the triad Triads, 3x5 cards Be Interviewed by another person Observe an interview and prepare to introduce the person that you did not interview 10 min Ask for Introductions Introduce one other person to group Discuss what was learned Debrief activity Whole group Activity – Icebreaker – Three Part, Four Step Interview Organizer: since we will be working together we need to get to know each other. Objective: observed. Interview each other and prepare an introduction of a person whose interview you Time: 30 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: Personal experience. 3x5 cards, flipchart, coloured pens In groups of three:  Interview one person in the triad. (name, background, goals, other)  Be interviewed by another person.  Observe an interview.  Prepare to introduce the person that you did not interview (your observation). Group Success: Everyone in the group has participated. Accountability: Debrief: Introduce one other person to the rest of the large group. What did you learn about your partners? About interviewing? 23 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Teambuilder – Treasure Hunt Purpose: To help set an atmosphere of positive interdependence. This is one example of how that might happen. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Set up groups Explain task Meet and introduce Decide responsibility Small groups, instructions 40 min Observe activity Find all the items listed Maps 20 min Debrief Awards Share what you have found Share rewards Whole group Activity – Teambuilder – Treasure Hunt Organizer: On the first day of a program, this activity will familiarize the participants with their college environment and introduce them more fully to each other. Objective: Find out a variety of things about the college. Time: 80 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: Instructions, maps. Monitor and encourage participation. In small groups of four or five:  Read over the instructions.  Decide who will be responsible for which parts of the hunt.  Find all of the items.  Explain to each member what you found out and how you found it. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain where to find all of the items. Accountability: Debrief: Report on the things that were discovered. What were your best strategies for getting information? Other teambuilders that help participants to see themselves as part of a small group include naming the group, sharing experiences, or developing guidelines (see next activity). 24 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Treasure Hunt Your task, as a group is to find out the following information and/or items, and bring them back to the classroom. The group that returns the fastest with the most accurate information and all the requested items, will receive a prize. To succeed, you have to talk to each other, decide how to best accomplish the task (and agree on that method), cooperate, share information and ask for information from various college people you encounter on your travels. Ensure you have a recorder before you start. Good luck and happy hunting! What is the address of this campus? Find the library and note its location on your map. If you don’t have one, get a library card. When you come back, everyone in your group should have a card. Where is the reference section in the library? If you need information in the library, where do you go first? Find Admissions and note its location on your map. Bring back two (2) brochures from different programs the college offers. Find Student Financial Assistance and note the location on your map. What is the name of someone who can help you there? Find Counselling and note its location on your map. What different kinds of counselling are available to you there? What are the names of the counsellors and the receptionist? What telephone number would you call to contact Counselling? Find the Security office and note its location on your map. Mark the location of as many security phones you can find on your map. What is the phone number for Security? Where can you obtain first aid help on this campus? What is the name of the Facilities Manager on this campus? Locate the office of the Facilities Manager and note it on your map. 25 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Find out as many names of the Security/First Aid/Facilities personnel as you can and write them here. Find the following and note the location of each on your map: Computer Labs Campus Dean Meeting Rooms Audio / Visual Services Learning Centre Cafeteria Conference Centre Bookstore Student Association What is the location of the Jobs Computer at this campus? What is the website address of the Job Placement Services at this college? How many computers are available for use in the computer labs? What hours are the computer labs open? How many children can the daycare take? What is the age span of children at the daycare? What are the cafeteria hours? What services does the Student Association provide? Find the Lost and Found office and note its location on your map. What are the Bookstore hours? Where are the pens and pencils located in the Bookstore? Where is the college newspaper published? Who publishes it? How often is it published? Bonus points: What interesting things did you discover that were NOT asked for on this hunt? 26 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Develop Communication Guidelines Purpose: To ensure that basic ground rules are set for good communication. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 30 min Pose question, “How do you want to receive information from team members?” Guide activity Create a list of guidelines for effective communications in your current groups Base groups, flipchart, pens, sticky pads 10 min Write group guidelines Debrief activity Clarify meaning of guidelines Describe group process whole group Activity – Develop Group Communication Guidelines Organizer: To work together effectively we need to communicate effectively. Objective: Create a list of guidelines for effective communications in your current groups. Time: 40 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: Discussion. Flipchart, coloured pens. In small (base) groups:  Discuss the question “How do you want to receive information from team members?”  Identify phrases, tone of voice, intent and methods that they would like others to use in communications.  Each group gives one guideline that the instructor then writes onto a flipchart. Repeat until all ideas are captured.  Clarification of phrases or values is done at this time. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain what the guidelines mean. Accountability: Share your small group list with the whole group to create a framework for communications that everyone can use. Debrief: these ideas? What differences arose over using some phrases or concepts? How did you clarify Follow-up: Revisit these guidelines at a later date to discuss if they have been useful or if the meanings have changed This accountability part of the communication guideline development is the most vital part because it allows each member of the team to be involved with the process of creating shared 27 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities meanings. It is important to complete the exercise by defining clearly what is meant by each of the suggested guidelines.    Confidentiality may mean different things to different people. Honesty with each other may range from nice to brutal, depending on the individual. The right to give information or not may be vital to building a feeling of safety into the group. 28 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Develop and Share Personal Goals Purpose: To make explicit personal goals in a workshop, course, or program. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 30 min Pose question, “What are your personal goals for this course?” Guide activity Create a list of personal goals for the course that you are willing to share Individual, flipchart, pens, sticky pads 10 min Lead presentation of personal goals Debrief activity Present personal goals to other group members Describe group process whole group Activity – Develop and Share Personal Goals Organizer: It is easier to achieve goals when they are explicit. Objective: Create a list of personal goals for the course that you are willing to share. Time: 30 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: Discussion. Flipchart, coloured pens. Individually and documented on a flipchart:  Create a list of personal goals for the course that you are willing to share. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain each other’s personal goals. Accountability: Share your list with the whole group to make goals explicit for everyone. Debrief: How difficult was it to describe your personal goals? How did you overcome this? Follow-up: Revisit these goals periodically to discuss if they have been met or changed. This accountability part of the goals exercise is the most vital part because it allows each member of the team to be involved with the process of creating shared meanings. It is important to maintain the exercise by revisiting the goals and identifying progress. 29 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Form Support Groups Purpose: To provide ongoing peer support over a period of time. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Organize suitable Base Groups Identify something they have in common Choose an identifying symbol or name and place on folder Base groups, folders, pens Arrange means of contact Debrief Whole group Guide activity 5 min Collect folders Guide debriefing Activity – Form Support Groups Organizer: To do your best, you need support. Objective: Form supportive (base or home) groups. Time: 25 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process:  Discussion, instructor set groups. Folders, and pens. In groups of three or four: Identify something they have in common.  Choose an identifying symbol or name.  Share how you can be contacted with your group. Group Success: Everyone in the group agrees on the name or symbol. Accountability: the group. Debrief: Produce a base or home group folder that can be used by the Instructor and How does the support of others assist your learning? 30 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Trust Building Purpose: To increase a sense of safety within groups. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Provide information on how trust affects group process Guide activity Brainstorm around the idea of trust as an important element of communication Whole group 10 min Provide group grid Collect strategies Debrief activity Complete group grid Discuss aids to process Base groups, group grids Activity – Trust Building Organizer: Trust or lack of it affects how groups perform. Objective: Identify ways to build trust in group and team situations. Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Interaction and discussion, information and personal experiences. Flipchart, pens, and group grids. Process: In the whole group:  Identify trust as an element of communication by exploring trust-building skills and their application.  Identify strategies to build trust that the instructor will collect on a flipchart. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the strategies used. Accountability: In base groups complete a group grid using suitable topic headings. (Topics should be related to activities or concepts that can be shared safely. As trust grows within the groups the topics may become more controversial.) Debrief: Explain to your base group members how the communication in your group helped each individual to participate. 31 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Group Grid Base Group Name date date date date Individual Topic Topic Topic Topic Name 1 2 3 4 32 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Form Formal Groups Purpose: To place participants into suitable groups. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities 20 min Organize suitable formal groups Share ways of moving teams for a specific project through the identified stages to Guide activity performing Formal groups, folders, pens 10 min Transcribe strategies Debrief activity whole group Share effective group development strategies Discuss aids to process Techniques / Equipment Activity – Form Formal Groups Organizer: Both Task and Interpersonal needs must be taken into account in group work. Objective: Form effective formal groups to complete a project. Time: 30 minutes Techniques / Equipment: and pens. Process: Instructor set groups, information on group processes. Flipchart, In groups of three or four:  Share ways of moving a team through the three stages to performing in both task behaviours and interpersonal behaviours.  Use the Tuckman model (or other) for reference but reflect on their own experiences and feelings. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the strategies to be used. Accountability: Select individuals at random to share ideas from their group. Transcribe on flipchart and have them typed up for distribution to all participants. Debrief: What benefit can you see from being aware of the stages of group process? 33 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Goal Setting Purpose: To build trust, open up conversations, and move people through the forming part of group development. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 15 min Ask participants to identify their goals Guide activity Identify why you are in this program Share goals with a partner Think, Pair, Share, flipchart, felt pens 15 min Collect and write goals Share goals with the whole group Whole group Activity – Goal Setting Organizer: Setting goals – Who am I? Why am I here? Objective: Identify why each person is in this program and to share goals. Time: 30 minutes (depends on group size) Techniques / Equipment: paper. Process: Flipchart, and felt pens. Write and group major goals on flipchart Individually, think about: Why am I here? Who is paying? Do I care? What do I want to get from this program? In pairs:  Share your answers and listen to the other person’s answers.  Identify similar and different goals. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the goals identified. Accountability: Debrief: Share your goals with the larger group. Are there goals that have been shared that could also fit into your goals? 34 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Group Processing Purpose: To ensure that there is analysis of interactions and promotion of teamwork. This process is also a strong tool for moving cognitive knowledge into long term memory. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Pose questions for discussion Identify how the group interacted and possible improvements Work groups Guide activity Activity – Group Processing Organizer: understand. How we work together affects the amount of material that we learn and Objective: Identify learning situations that assisted understanding and prepare for next time. Time: 10 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process:   Discussion. In the small groups that worked together, discuss: What happened. How the group worked together  What could be done better next time. Group Success: Everyone in the group has explained their strategies for next time. Accountability: What conclusions have you reached? 35 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Share Experiences and Feelings Purpose: To open up the discussion about strong feelings that may accompany an event so that the participants are able to process the affective content of the experience. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Describe discussion topic Guide activity Identify personal feelings about small groups, 10 min Listen and validate Debrief activity Share feelings with others Discuss how process affects you personally whole group Activity – Share Experiences and Feelings Organizer: Strong feelings accompany meaningful experiences, both positive and negative. Objective: Share experiences with and feelings about {for instance: a presentation, a video, a field trip, an emergency, or …}. Time: 30 minutes (depends on group size and strength of experience) Techniques / Equipment: Personal experience. Monitor and support participation to the level that individuals are willing or able. Process: In groups of three or four:  What is our experience with ?  What are the major feelings associated with the experience?  Discuss how this affects our interactions with others. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the feelings identified. Accountability: Each group member gets a chance to contribute in their group. A volunteer reports the main themes on behalf of their group. Debrief: What are the implications of these experiences to you? 36 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Classbuilder – Wanted Poster Purpose: To help set the atmosphere in a group who have been together before. Classbuilders do this and can be quite cooperative. This is one example of how that might happen. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Set up pairs, Observe activity Identify a partner Pairs, Icebreaker 20 min Debrief activity Introduce a partner Whole group Activity – Classbuilder – Wanted Poster Organizer: At this point in time you have spent a full semester with each other and are coming back from a break. Objective: Introduce another member of the class with outlaw theme. Time: 40 minutes (depends on group size) Techniques / Equipment: Process: Pairs, Wanted Poster Blanks. Monitor and encourage participation. In pairs:  Pair up with someone who you got to know quite well last semester.  Interview each other with regard to your holidays and information to fill out Wanted Posters. Group Success: Both people have completed their poster. Accountability: Introduce your partner to the rest of the class on the basis of Wanted Poster information. Ensure instructor gets introduced. Debrief: What information did you learn about your partner or others? Other classbuilders that help participants to see themselves as part of a larger group include using a thumb-up or thumb-down poll of the class to compare reactions to an idea, or indicating by a show of fingers (scale of one to five) how sure you are about an answer. 37 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities WANTED NAME ___________ REWARD: AKA (ALIAS): DISTINGUISHING FEATURES: KNOWN TO SAY, “ .” OFTEN FOUND (WHERE?): WANTED BY: WANTED FOR: THINKS THE MOST IMPORTANT THING FOR A TO REMEMBER ABOUT IS: 38 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Classbuilder – Matching Icons Purpose: To help set the atmosphere in a group who have been together before. Classbuilders do this and be individualistic. This is one example of how that might happen. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Set up pairs, Observe activity Identify icon matches Pairs, Icons, table 20 min Debrief activity Identify what and why of icons, tally score Whole group Activity – Classbuilder – Matching Icons Organizer: At this point in time you have been part of a class together and are coming back from a break. Objective: Identify class members through an icon that they have provided anonymously. Time: 40 minutes (depends on group size) Techniques / Equipment: Pairs, Icons brought anonymously by each person and displayed by the instructor, table of names. Monitor and encourage participation (may have prize for high scoring pair). Process: Individually:  Supply an icon anonymously (day before or wrapped) In Pairs:  Identify which icon matches which group member. Group Success: Both people have completed their table. Accountability: of correct matches. Each person explains the what and why of their icon, and identifies score Debrief: True icon matches are revealed to the whole group. What information did you learn about your partner and others? 39 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Matching Icons Name Which Icon? Which Icon! 40 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Group Closure Purpose: To bring about the finalization of a group experience. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Pose questions for discussion Guide activity Identify how the group interacted and possible improvements Formal groups 10 min. Direct groups to recognize ideas Identify one idea or action that that helped group process each person in your group contributed Formal groups Activity – Group Closure Organizer: How we have worked together affects the amount of learning that we take away when a group is over. Objective: Identify learning situations that assisted understanding. Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: Discussion. In formal work groups at the end of a task:  Identify ideas and actions that helped the group achieve its goals.  How could the process be made better next time. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the goals identified. Accountability: Identify one idea or action that each person in their group contributed and tell that person directly. 41 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities GROUP ACTIVITIES FOR GROUP FUNCTION 43 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Constructive Communication Strategies Purpose: To practise positive (as opposed to negative) communication skills. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Provide information on constructive communication Guide activity Identify and give the context for Base group, constructive communication flipchart, pens strategies 10 min Collect communications strategies Debrief activity Share effective communication strategies Discuss aids to process Whole group Activity – Constructive Communication Strategies Organizer: Constructive communication helps to get the job done. Objective: Identify and give the context for constructive communication strategies to accomplish as particular task {for instance: to complete a project that culminates in a presentation by the group}. Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: Discussion, information and personal experiences. In base groups:   Discuss and give examples of ways to encourage constructive communication. Experiment with positive communication methods and their effectiveness in the individual groups. Group Success: Everyone in the group can identify the communication methods. Accountability: Debrief: Share effective communication strategies with the whole group. Identify how constructive communication assists in completing tasks. 44 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities “I” Language Purpose: To identify the elements of and practise giving descriptive feedback. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Provide information on “I” language Guide activity Practise speaking descriptively rather than evaluatively Pairs, pairs of pairs, Worksheet 10 min Collect strategies Identify the difference between speaking descriptively and speaking evaluatively Discuss difference in feeling Whole group Debrief activity Activity – “I” Language Organizer: When we speak from the “I” position we can communicate so that others can listen and hear us. Objective: Practise speaking descriptively rather than evaluatively. Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: Worksheet In pairs:  Fill in the worksheet with appropriate descriptive statements. In pairs of pairs  Compare statements.  Explain and edit as necessary. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the phrases identified. Accountability: Share information on the difference between speaking descriptively and speaking evaluatively. Debrief: How would you feel hearing the evaluative comment? How would you feel hearing the descriptive comment? 45 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities “I” Language Worksheet Instructions With a partner, rewrite each of the evaluative “you” language statements below using descriptive “I” language. “Don’t you ever do that again.” ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ “Why can’t you be on time?” ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ “I wish you’d try to be more reasonable.” ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ “You always take, but you never give anything back.” ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ “You don’t respect my property.” ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ “Why won’t you listen to me?” ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ 46 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Feedback Basics Purpose: When is feedback useful and timely for someone else? Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Provide information Guide activity Work interactively on Objective group, equipment 10 min Complete accountability Debrief activity Achieve content objective Discuss aids to process Whole group Activity – Ping Pong Ball Toss (developed by Lorraine Robson, BCIT) Organizer: Feedback is something that we tend to be able to deliver, but do we do it well? What is effective and useful feedback? Objective: Participate in delivering and receiving feedback and determine the effectiveness of different types of feedback. Pre Assessment: Can the learner already accomplish this skill? Time: 10 Minutes. Techniques / Equipment: A set of at least three (3) ping-pong balls (crumpled paper or nerf type balls would also work), a basket at which to toss the balls, and a blind-fold to put on a volunteer. Monitor and support participation and the exchange of ideas. Process: Can be done in large or small groups. A volunteer is requested from the group for a safe activity. The volunteer will be asked if they would participate in an exercise that involves wearing a blind-fold and doing an activity with the rest of the class. Nothing unusual will happen to them and they can quit at any time. They are asked to leave the room for about 2 minutes. (If you have someone who can accompany them out of the room, this is a more comfortable process.) When the person leaves the room, the instructor will brief the rest of the class.      When the volunteer enters the room, they will be asked to put on a blind-fold and throw three balls into a basket that has been placed in front of them. Once the blind-fold is in place, one member of the class will quietly put the basket in place so the volunteer is not aware of its location. They will be asked to throw the balls into the basket. This process will be repeated four (4) times. During the first attempt, the rest of the class will remain silent as each ball is thrown The volunteer will be asked if they are willing to continue to throw another three balls. During the second attempt, the rest of the class will deliver only negative comments that do not indicate the level of skill or how close they were. (e.g. lousy shot, rubber arm, Ohhhh, too bad, etc.) The volunteer will be asked if they are willing to continue to throw another three balls. 47 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities  During the third attempt, the rest of the class will deliver only positive comments that do not indicate the level of skill or how close they were. (e.g. Way to go, nice one, good form, etc.)  The volunteer will be asked if they are willing to continue to throw one last set of three balls.  During the final attempt, the rest of the class will deliver useful feedback that will assist the volunteer to get the ball into the basket. (e.g. a little to the left, a little harder and to the right, just a little further, etc.)  After the fourth throw, the blind-fold is removed and only the volunteer is asked to speak and tell the group how they felt during each attempt and their reaction to the feedback that they received when throwing the ball. Group Success / Assessment: When is feedback useful? What type of feedback is of most use to someone? Accountability: an activity? How does the feedback that I deliver assist others in achieving success in Debrief: in a group. The group discusses how useful and specific feedback his helpful to their learning Summary: The feedback that we give others must be useful and timely in order to help them. 48 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Paraphrasing Purpose: To practise language that clarifies and moves the conversation. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Provide information on paraphrasing Guide activity Chose topic Triads 10 min Collect helps and hindrances Debrief activity Discuss what was easy and what was difficult Practise paraphrasing Whole group Activity – Paraphrasing Organizer: Paraphrasing helps the assure others that they are being heard and ensures that what is heard is understood. Objective: Practise accurate paraphrasing. Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: Personal experience Form triads: Speaker   Choose a personal experience to share with your listener. Spend four minutes expressing your thoughts and feelings about the experience. Listener     Spend four minutes actively listening to your partner. Use only paraphrasing the speaker’s content. Add no new content No questions, no advice, no opinions! Observer  Focus on paraphrasing skills of listener.  Debrief your observations for three minutes.  Sandwich your feedback (positive, negative, positive). Rotate positions so that everyone has done every role. Group Success: Everyone in the group has participated actively. Accountability: Everyone has done all of the roles. Debrief: How accurate were you? What was easy? What was difficult? What helped? 49 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Active Listening I Purpose: To identify the basic skills of active listening. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 40 min Provide information on how active listening improves communication Guide activity Practise active listening with an observer Triads, observer feedback grids 20 min Provide observer sheets for feedback Debrief activity Give positive feedback Triads, Discuss aids to process whole group Activity – Practise Active Listening Organizer: The ability to listen actively increases communications. Objective: Practise active listening skills through accurate paraphrasing, empathy and appropriate paralanguage. Time: 60 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: Personal experience. Observer feedback grids In triads:  Choose something “real” about which you truly do have authentic feelings {for instance: a strong personal experience, a position on a controversy, etc.}.  The speaker will explain the “situation” for three minutes.  The listener will practise active listening using paraphrasing, empathy and paralanguage.  The observer will take notes on the skills that the listener is practising.  The observer will give positive feedback and share their notes with the speaker and the listener.  Complete the cycle twice (six speakers). Group Success: Everyone in the group has participated actively. Accountability: The triad members will switch roles and practise so that everyone has a chance to do all three roles twice. Debrief: How did the feedback affect your ability to listen actively? 50 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Active Listening Observer Feedback Grid Name First Time Listening Second Time Listening Comments Comments Appropriate Tone of Voice Accurate Paraphrasing Empathy Appropriate Paralanguage Encouraging Words Other 51 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Active Listening II Purpose: To practise a variety of listening skills. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 40 min Provide information on active listening and blocking Guide activity Brainstorm topics. Small groups 20 min Collect useful strategies Identify the difference between using blocks and active listening. Discuss what was easy and what was difficult. Debrief activity Practise blocks and active listening. whole group Activity – Paraphrasing Organizer: Active listening helps to assure others that they are being heard and ensures that what is heard is understood. Objective: Practise paraphrasing with blocks and with active listening. Time: 60 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process:  Personal experience. In the whole group: Brainstorm a list of a dozen topics to use in practising active listening. The topics would be those that have an interest to the participants. Form triads: Blocks. Rotate speaker, listener and observer. Speaker   Choose a personal experience to share with your listener, Spend 3 minutes communicating your thoughts and feelings about the experience. Listener    Choose one of the “blocks” to effective paraphrasing. Emphasize your “block” exclusively. Stay with your “block” until your observer / timekeeper indicates your time is up. Observer  Attend to body language of both “listener” and speaker. 52 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities  Focus on the “block” the “listener” is demonstrating.  Keep track of time.  Debrief your observations. Active Listening. Rotate speaker, active listener and observer. Speaker   Choose a personal experience to share with your listener. Spend four minutes communicating your thoughts and feelings about the experience. Listener   Spend four minutes actively listening to your partner. Use only paraphrasing and empathy.   Add no new content No questions, no advice, no opinions! Observer  Focus on paraphrasing and empathy skills of listener.  Attend to body language of listener and speaker.  Keep track of time.  Debrief your observations for three minutes.  Sandwich your feedback (positive, negative, positive). Group Success: Everyone in the group has participated actively. Accountability: Debrief: Everyone has done all of the roles. How did the two experiences compare? What was easy? What was difficult? 53 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Active Listening Tape Purpose: To be able to hear oneself as others do. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 30 min Identify criteria to complete tape Observe activity Create an Active Listening tape with a partner Pairs; tapes, tape recorder 10 min Collect tapes for review Complete tape and submit Describe challenges and celebration Whole group Debrief activity Assignment – Create an Active Listening Tape Organizer: The ability to listen actively increases communications. Objective: Create a five minute tape demonstrating your active listening skills through paraphrasing and empathy. Time: 40 minutes Techniques / Equipment: recorders. Process:     Situations supplied from personal experience, tapes, and tape In pairs: Choose something “real” about which you truly do have authentic feelings. With the tape recorder running, the speaker will explain their “situation”. The listener will practise active listening using paraphrasing and empathy. The tape will be as recorded at one time with no editing.  The same pair will switch roles and make a second tape. Group Success: Both people have participated actively. Accountability: Submit both tapes to the instructor. Debrief: What were the challenges to be dealt with to complete the tape? How do we celebrate our success? 54 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Perception Checking Purpose: To limit assumptions and enhance understanding. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 15 min Provide information on how perception checking helps communication Guide activity Practise Perception Checking with activity Complete worksheet Pairs, perception checking worksheet 10 min Collect responses. Share best responses with group. Discuss aids to process Whole group Debrief activity Activity – Perception Checking Organizer: Assumptions about what is happening need to be checked for accuracy. Objective: Create and use effective perception checking. Time: 25 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: Perception checking worksheet In pairs:  Complete the Perception Checking Activity, discussing the items and synthesizing appropriate answers. Group Success: Both people have participated actively. Accountability: Share examples of your responses with the whole group. Debrief: What elements of perception checking are easiest and hardest? How did your partner help or hinder your perception checking? 55 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Perception Checking Worksheet Instructions    With a partner, write perception-checking statements for the following items. Practise saying these statements out loud to each other. Refine the statements to enable more complete perception checking. Example: You saw your friend talking intently with Pat, your recent date. Perception-checking statement: “When I saw you talking with Pat, I didn’t know what was happening. It seemed like you might be discussing the class that you are taking together or you might have a more personal interest in each other. Are you interested in Pat as a friend or a date?”  Ever since the beginning of the program, your family members ask you how you are doing every week. _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________  An instructor has returned an exam with a low grade to you , commenting that “This kind of work paints a bleak picture for the future.” You have approached him to discuss that remark. _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________  You are talking long distance with an old friend and she remarks, “Oh, it’s okay, I guess,” about her current job. _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ 56 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities  You come home and your roommate is reading on the couch. When you say “Hi,” she turns away from you and keeps on reading. _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________  You have been given a big assignment at work. Your supervisor asks you regularly if you are having any problems with it. _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________  Your romantic partner tells you that he is planning to spend next Friday night with friends from work. You usually spend Friday nights together. _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________  A week ago your neighbour raked a large amount of garden debris into a pile next to your property, promising to clean it up the next day. It is still there and blowing into your yard. _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________  One of the people at your workplace has been looking at you a lot lately. Every time you look up, she is looking and smiling at you. You have decided to ask her why. _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ 57 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Quality Team Assessment Purpose: To practise self assessment and build critical thinking skills. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Provide Quality Chart Guide activity Perform a self-assessment on formal work how well the group is doing and groups, possible areas for improvement Quality Chart 10 min Coach plan development Develop a plan for team improvement. Debrief and encourage Identify starting point Formal work groups Activity – Quality Team Assessment Organizer: How well are you doing in your team? Objective: Conduct a team self-assessment and develop a plan for improvement. Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: Discussion, Quality Charts. In formal work groups:  Using the Quality Team Chart, conduct a self-assessment and discuss the group’s ability to accomplish the items on the list. This is not evaluative, but is meant to establish a benchmark for celebration and/or improvement.  Identify one area in which they would like to improve and propose ways for achieving that goal as a team. Group Success: Everyone in the group has participated actively. Accountability: Debrief: Group members share strategies for improvement with the large group. What is one goal that you can start on immediately? This exercise is repeated regularly and records kept over the time that the group is together to indicate how each team is working together. 58 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Team Quality Chart Names Timelines Cooperation / Teamwork Responsibility Adaptability / Versatility Quality of Work Initiative Dependability Attendance Communication Contribution 59 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Negotiating Compromise Purpose: To practise conflict management skills. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 15 min Provide information Guide activity and discussion Identify and group areas of conflict that might arise Small groups 15 min Collect cards of strategies Identify negotiation strategies to Whole group manage conflict in teams Discuss aids to process Debrief activity Activity – Negotiating Compromise Organizer: All teams have internal conflicts. The best teams identify and negotiate solutions to these conflicts. Objective: Share strategies and best practises for internal team conflict management and problem solving Time: 30 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: Discussion, sticky notes, index cards, written materials In groups of three or four:  Brainstorm types of internal team conflicts on sticky notes or index cards {for instance: missing meetings, work not done on time, etc.}.  Group the types of conflicts into related clusters.  Identify strategies that they have or could use to negotiate to manage conflict or solve a team problem with reference to the written materials.  Transcribe these strategies in point form on cards. Group Success: Everyone in the group can identify the group strategies. Accountability: Share positive strategies with the whole group. The instructor collects the point-form strategies and has them word processed and distributed to the participants. Debrief: What was one strategy that you could use right away? 60 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities ACTIVITIES TO PROMOTE ACCOUNTABILITY 61 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Numbered Heads Together Purpose: To ensure there is random individual accountability. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 2 min Randomly select numbers to identify who will report Be individually accountable in team or group situations Numbered Heads Together Activity – Numbered Heads Together Organizer: Ensuring that that the same person is not picked each time. Objective: Encourage individual accountability of group members. Time: 2 minutes within another activity Techniques / Equipment: Dice (4 sided, 6 sided, etc.), number cards, etc. for randomly selecting group members. Keep process light and allow for group support of reporter. Celebrate effort as well as ideas. Process: In groups of three or four who are completing another task:  Have students in each group number 1 to 4. Group Success: Everyone in the group is ready to report. Accountability: Debrief: When group is to report select reporter by number. How did your team help support you and prepare you for answering? 62 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Terror Cards Purpose: To ensure individual accountability and alertness. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 2 min randomly select card to identify who will participate. Be individually accountable in team or group situations Index cards Activity – Terror Cards Organizer: Ensuring that the same person is not picked and that there is random individual accountability. Objective: Encourage individual accountability of group members. Time: 2 minutes within another activity Techniques / Equipment: Process: Pens, index cards. In a whole group:  Have students write their first name and initial on an index card.  Hand the cards to the instructor. Group Success: Everyone in the group is ready to respond. Accountability: When group is to participate select participant by picking a card. Card is then returned to the pack making them “Terror” cards. Debrief: Celebrate effort as well as performance. 63 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Develop and Implement a Coaching Plan Purpose: To develop a coaching relationship with a particular person. Time Learner Activities Instructor Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Identify ways to develop a coaching relationship with a particular person Present Coaching Worksheet Guide activity Individually, worksheets 30 min Use Action Plan to coach another person Be coached by another and give feedback Observe a coaching conversation and give feedback Describe Activity Guide activity Threes, worksheets 10 min Share your experience and learning Debrief activity Whole group Debrief process Work groups 3 min Describe group process Activity – Develop and Implement a Coaching Plan Organizer: We have learned, written and discussed using communication techniques, now we are going to practice them in a coaching situation. Objective: 1. Develop an action plan to coach another person. 2. Practise coaching another person. 3. Receive feedback on your coaching behaviours. 4. Observe coaching behaviours. 5. Give feedback on another person’s coaching behaviours. Time: 55 minutes Techniques / Equipment: exchange of ideas. Process: Coaching Worksheet. Monitor and support participation and the Individually  Using a personal situation and the provided worksheet, identify strategies and steps for coaching, including: a) What extra information do you need before you can proceed? b) What is the first thing you say or do? c) What will your general course of action be? In groups of three (or four) with one person coaching, one person being coached, and one (or 2) person observing: 64 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Person 1 coaches Person 2 on a specific behaviours for 3-5 minutes while the observer observes. The Observer gives feedback for 2 minutes on what they have seen Person 2 gives feedback for 2 minutes on how the coaching was for them Person 1 listens and adjusts their action plan to reflect the feedback Each person in the group rotates through each position. All members of the group Group Success: Everyone in the group has practised coaching and adjusting their coaching plan, being coached, and observing. Accountability: Debrief: Share your experiences with the larger group. What feelings and difficulties arise for you when coaching others? 65 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities GROUP ACTIVITIES FOR KNOWLEDGE AND COMPREHENSION 67 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Think-Pair-Share Purpose: To ensure maximum discussion within a group. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Present Guide activity Share information on and feelings about Think-PairShare; written materials 10 min Collect and comment on information Debrief activity Share information and feelings Whole group Discuss aids to process Activity – Think-Pair-Share Organizer: Increases the discussion on . Objective: Share information on and feelings about . Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: participation. Process: Details of a case, situation or question. Monitor and encourage Individually:  Think about the situation and it’s implications. In pairs:  Discuss the situation and your thoughts around the situation. Group Success: Both people can explain the point of view of the other. Accountability: Share the information and personal feelings about with others. Debrief: Identify how discussing the situation added to how well you could identify your feelings about the situation. Identify how sharing information added to how well you know the material. 68 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Search-Pair-Share Purpose: To increase the amount of information sharing in a search. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 30 min Provide information on for research Identify reference material for Pairs, written materials 10 min Collect and comment on sources Debrief activity List sources Whole group Discuss aids to process Activity – Search-Pair-Share Organizer: When a reference is needed it may be cumbersome to locate. It is easier when material has been previewed and references organized in advance. Objective: Identify reference material for and create a reference list. Time: 30 minutes Techniques / Equipment: encourage participation. Process: Written text materials, flipchart, and felt pens. Monitor and In pairs:  Find as many references to in the reference material within the next 10 minutes.  Summarize the topic and main points of the passage. Group Success: Both people can explain the main points. Accountability: Pairs share their references and information with the whole group. A combined list of references is created. Debrief: What were the differences that you saw in how your pair and other pairs searched for references? How did this affect the length of the compiled list? 69 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Pair Read Purpose: To increase comprehension by using shared readings. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 25 min Provide information Guide activity Describe information on Pairs, written information 10 min Ensure comprehension Debrief activity Answer questions on content Discuss group process Whole group Activity – Pair Read Objective: Describe Time: 35 minutes (5 min set up, 2x10 for pair reading, 10 min debrief) Techniques / Equipment: one copy of information to each person. Monitor and encourage participation. Process: Individually:  Silently read each paragraph or section and then In Pairs:  Take turns describing the content to their partner. Discrepancies in understanding are discussed as needed.  When each pair finishes they can discuss the entire passage. Group Success: Both people in the group can describe the passage content. Accountability: Debrief: Randomly answer questions on content. Was this an effective means of covering this material for you? Why or why not? 70 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Jigsaw Purpose: To require that students interdependently learn from one another. The initial jigsaw technique was first developed in the early 1970s by Elliot Aronson and his students at the University of Texas and the University of California and published in Aronson (1978). Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Form groups and present written information Guide activity Learn and rehearse materials Expert groups, segmented information 20 Ensure major points are correct Teach materials to others Learn new material Home groups 20 min Give test Debrief activity Take test Identify group process Individually, whole group Activity – Jigsaw (2 part) Organizer: Students are assigned to small heterogeneous teams, and the materials to be learned are divided into as many sections as there are team members. First, members of the different teams who have the same section form "expert" groups and study together. Each then returns to his or her team and teaches that section to his or her teammates. Objective: Use expert groups to cognitively rehearse information. Time: 60 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Ensure accuracy. Process: Segmented information. Monitor and encourage participation. Working in expert groups of three or four:  Half of the groups take the information on and the other half take the information on  Discuss and summarize the major points of the material.  Use cognitive rehearsal in the groups to prepare to teach their part to a partner from another group. In pairs formed with one person from each expert group:  The expert will explain their portion to their partner so that they understand it clearly. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the material. Accountability: Question to random members of the home group regarding non-expert information comprehension and retention. Or, a short test on the information will be given to 71 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities ensure that the material has been learned. Using the points above, have the participants write a short description under each heading. Debrief: material? How did the explanations of others and your questions assist in understanding the Activity – Jigsaw (3 part) Organizer: Objective: Use expert groups to cognitively rehearse information. Time: 60 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Ensure accuracy. Process: Segmented information. Monitor and encourage participation. Number participants off in their home groups 1 to 3.  Each number group receives information on one area of . In expert groups (all the 1s, all the 2s, etc.):  Discuss and summarize the major points of the material.  Use cognitive rehearsal to prepare to teach their part to others in their home groups. In home groups, made up of one of each type of expert.  Each expert will explain their portion so the rest of the group understands it. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the material. Accountability: Question to random members of the home group regarding non-expert information comprehension and retention (or, a short test on the information will be given to ensure that the material has been learned). Using the points above, have the participants write a short description under each heading. Debrief: material? How did the explanations of others and your questions assist in understanding the Activity – Jigsaw (4 part) Organizer: Objective: Use expert groups to cognitively rehearse information. Time: 60 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Ensure accuracy. Process: Segmented information. Monitor and encourage participation. Number participants off in their home groups 1 to 4.  Each number group receives information on one area of . In expert groups (all the 1s, all the 2s, etc.): 72 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities  Discuss and summarize the major points of the material.  Use cognitive rehearsal to prepare to teach their part to others in their home groups. In home groups are made up of one of each type of expert.  Each expert will explain their portion so the rest of the group understands it. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the material. Accountability: Question to random members of the home group regarding non-expert information comprehension and retention. Or, a short test on the information will be given to ensure that the material has been learned. Using the points above, have the participants write a short description under each heading. Debrief: How did the explanations of others and your questions assist in understanding the material? or Which step do you have the best understanding of at this time? Which step are you least clear about? 73 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Nightmare Cards Purpose: To bring out fears so that they can be handled. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Pose and ask for nightmares Guide activity Identify the worst case scenarios that you can imagine for Pairs, 5x7 cards, felt pens 10 min Collect cards for reference Debrief activity Discuss scenarios and perceptions Whole group Activity – Nightmare Cards Organizer: What we don’t know how to deal with may make us quite nervous. Objective: Identify imaginary but realistic worst case scenarios for situations. Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: and agenda issues. Process: 5x7 cards, felt pens. Retain Nightmare Cards for future reference Individually:  Write out a scenario that they dread (real or imagined). In pairs:  Discuss the Nightmare scenarios. Group Success: Both people can identify the feelings of the other. Accountability: review. Scenarios are described to the whole group. Group posts scenarios for Debrief: How does discussing “worst case scenarios” change your perception of what might happen and what you might do about it? 74 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Define Categories from Experiences Purpose: To build shared meaning around a category that everyone has experienced but may nor be clearly defined. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Describe discussion topic Guide activity Identify personal feelings about small groups, 10 min Listen and validate Debrief activity Share feelings with others Discuss how process affects you personally whole group Activity – Share Experiences and Feelings Organizer: We may all think that we know what means and implies but can we describe it clearly for ourselves and others? Objective: By sharing best experiences about {for instance: a learning, teaching, response to a situation, or …} the participants will build a definition and shared meaning of the category. Time: 30 minutes (depends on group size and length of experience) Techniques / Equipment: Personal experience. Monitor and support participation to the level that individuals are willing or able. Process: In groups of three or four:  What is our experience with ?  What was the best parts of the experience?  Discuss how this affects our interactions with others now and in the future. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the best elements and their effects. Accountability: Each group member gets a chance to contribute in their group. A volunteer reports the main themes on behalf of their group. Debrief: What are the implications of these experiences to you? 75 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Flash Cards Purpose: To learn rote materials in a supportive atmosphere. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Provide terminology and definitions Guide activity Memorize terminology Pair, 5x7 cards, felt pens 10 min Set situations. Debrief activity Use terminology appropriately Describe group process Whole group Activity – Use Flash Cards Organizer: The technical jargon of must be used naturally. Objective: Memorize and use appropriate terminology Time: 30 minutes Techniques / Equipment: exchange of ideas. Process:  5x7 cards, felt pens. Monitor and encourage participation and the Working in pairs: Prepare Flash Cards of terminology.  Use them with each other to rehearse material.  Terms from previous sections can be added to the list. Terminology:  Group Success: Both people can identify the terminology. Accountability: Use the terminology in appropriate ways and contexts. Debrief: What were the easiest terms to learn? What were the hardest terms to learn? What made a difference? 76 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Visualization Purpose: To expand on networks and connections of ideas. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 15 min Present the basic elements of concept or situation Guide activity Analyze and link Pairs, whole group, flipchart, felt pens 10 min Comment on linkages. Debrief activity Identify linked areas Discuss aids to process Whole group Activity – Visualization Organizer: Objective: Analyze and link various {for instance: how do various theoretical frameworks link to each other.}. Time: 25 minutes Techniques / Equipment: the exchange of ideas. Process: Flipchart and felt pens. Monitor and encourage participation and Have the participant visualize  Individually think of what do. Imagine ways that they are or could be linked.  Make notes about your thoughts.  In pairs share with your partner.  Report list and instructor records on flipchart. Group Success: Both people can identify what their partner was visualizing. Accountability: In the large group identify where are the overlaps between pairs. How would the linkages imagined be made what would the effect be? Debrief: How did other people’s points help you to develop your concepts? 77 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Follow a Process Purpose: To follow a procedural process. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Provide information Guide activity Identify the linear steps of Pairs, written materials 10 min Collect and comment on steps Present steps in context Whole group Debrief activity Describe group process Activity – Follow a Process Organizer: here>. Use the assigned pre-reading as an organizer for . Time: 30 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: written materials . Monitor and encourage participation. In pairs:  Identify the end product of the procedure.  Identify the first step of the procedure.  Trace the necessary step to reach the end product. Group Success: Both people can trace the same steps in the process. Accountability: Debrief: Identify steps that may not be necessary, but may be useful. What parts of the process are clear? What parts still need more explanation? 78 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Trace a Continuum Purpose: To use graphics to follow a history continuum. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 15 min Present information on history of Create a graphic of the information continuum Numbered Heads Together 10 min Comment on graphics. Debrief activity Share continuum graphic Discuss aids to process Whole group Activity – Trace a Continuum Organizer: Present information on history of . Objective: Create a graphic of the continuum of . Time: 25 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Presentation of information and history. Monitor and encourage participation and the exchange of ideas. Process:  In groups of three or four: Trace the sequence of events, from beginning to completion.  Graph the information as a continuum. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the continuum used. Accountability: Compare different ways the process has been broken down and named and report them to the whole group. Debrief: How did a visual representation assist your understanding of this history? 79 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Pair Review Form Completion Purpose: To ensure that forms are completed. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Set participants to fill in forms with information Guide activity Compare and revise forms Pairs, forms, writing implements 10 min Comment on forms Debrief activity Present revised forms Identify aids to process Whole group Activity –Pair Review Form Completion Organizer: Peer editing increases completion levels. Objective: Compare and revise forms with another participant. Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Forms and writing implements. Monitor and encourage participation and the exchange of ideas. Process: In the large group:  Ask clarifying questions and review information required for forms. Individually:  Individually complete the forms. In pairs:  After three minutes pair with someone new and compare forms. Group Success: Everyone has contributed to the forms. Accountability: Submit revised forms at the end of the class (signed and dated). Debrief: How does your level of completion before peer editing compare with how complete your information was after? What did your partner help you with? 80 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Discussion – Small Group – Knowledge Purpose: To clarify characteristics of things or systems. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 15 min Identify the elements of Guide activity Discuss Small groups 10 min Collect information. Describe characteristics of materials Describe group process Whole group Debrief activity Activity – Discussion – Knowledge Organizer: Objective: Describe characteristics of {for instance: any complex system with many characteristics}. Time: 25 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Personal experience, written information on . Monitor and encourage participation and the exchange of ideas. Process: In groups of three or four:  Read characteristic.  Expand characteristic with a description.  Provide an observable consequence.  Are there other characteristics? Add them. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the characteristics. Accountability: group activity. Debrief: Describe each characteristic by randomly calling on members to report on How did your group members add to your knowledge? 81 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Discussion – Small Group – Comprehension Purpose: To encourage discussion and clarification of ideas. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 15 min Pose question or outline situation Guide activity Exchange ideas and explain Small groups 10 min Collect comments Debrief activity Explain ideas discussed Describe group process Whole group Activity – Discussion – Comprehension Organizer: Objective: Exchange ideas and explain in your own words {for instance: any complex topic with new or controversial information}. Time: 25 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Information, personal experience. Monitor and encourage participation and the exchange of ideas. Process: In groups of three or four:  Exchange ideas on the following statement, presentation or reading. ? Group Success: produced. Everyone in the group can explain the ideas and context that the group Accountability: Explain your ideas within an appropriate context. Debrief: class? How do the individual statements of understanding match the context presented in 82 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Discussion – Small Group – Factors to be Considered Purpose: situation. To encourage identification and discussion of factors to be considered in a given Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 15 min Pose question on factors in a given situation Guide activity Discuss factors to be considered Small groups in the situation Exchange ideas and explain how factors will be addressed 10 min Collect strategies Debrief activity Explain strategies discussed Describe group process Whole group Activity – Discussion – Comprehension Organizer: Objective: Discuss factors affecting and exchange ideas for strategies to address factors. Time: 25 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Information, personal experience. Monitor and encourage participation and the exchange of ideas. Process: In groups of three or four:  Discuss the following question. What factors must be considered for ?  Exchange ideas and explain how these factors will be addressed. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the factors and strategies to address them that the group produced. Accountability: Explain your strategies within an appropriate context. Debrief: How does discussing the factors affect your perception of what might happen and what you might do about it? 83 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Pair Review Note Taking Purpose: To collaborate in reviewing each others notes for accuracy and understanding. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Set participants to identify main elements Guide activity Compare and revise notes on Pairs, paper, writing implements 10 min Collect materials. Debrief activity Submit signed revised notes Discuss group process Whole group Activity – Note Taking / Pair Review Organizer: retention. Cognitive rehearsal by stating ideas orally and in writing increases content Objective: Compare and revise notes on with another participant. Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: Paper and writing implements, individual notes. In the large group:  Ask clarifying questions and review material. Individually:  Summarize the main points of the lesson in point form. In pairs:  After three minutes pair with someone new and compare notes.  Revise personal notes. Group Success: Everyone in the group has given feedback for revisions. Accountability: (signed and dated). Have each participant submit their revised notes at the end of the class Debrief: How does what you know compare with what you think that you need to know? What are you doing with this realization? Return notes at the next class with comments and clarification. Go over the main points and fill in missing elements. 84 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Formulate a Report Purpose: To practise formulating and editing reports. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Identify elements of report writing Guide activity Formulate a report on Edit the report with a partner Individual, Pair edit, situations 10 min Review finished reports Debrief activity Review report with partner Discuss process challenges Pair edit {For instance: The following activity is based on formulating Incident Reports but the reports could be on a variety of subjects such as meetings, projects, or any activity.} Assignment – Formulate an Incident Report Organizer: Report writing is a necessary part of . Objective: Formulate reports for . Time: 30 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process:  Situation resources (audio, video, written) Working individually: Use the situations and other resources for the appropriate information.  Identify the critical elements from the information.  Formulate a short report, using a format. In pairs:  Read and comment on each other’s report draft.  Re-work the report. Group Success: Everyone in the group has given feedback for revisions. Accountability: to the instructor. Debrief: frame? Share the report with the whole group. Submit the signed and dated reports What were the challenges to be dealt with to complete the report within the time 85 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Prepare Reports Purpose: To identify the elements needed and to prepare reports. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Identify elements of reports for Guide activity Discuss report elements Identify where information comes from Individual, Pair edit, situations 10 min Review finished reports Debrief activity Edit the report with a partner Discuss challenges Pair edit {For instance: reports could be on a variety of subjects such as meetings, projects, or any activity.} Assignment – Prepare Reports Organizer: Report writing is a necessary part of . Objective: Identify elements and prepare reports for . Time: 30 minutes Techniques / Equipment: participation Process: Report samples, personal experience. Monitor and encourage Working individually:  Use the situations and other resources for the appropriate information.  Identify the critical elements from the information and how to acquire them.  Formulate a short report, using a format. In pairs:  Read and comment on each other’s report draft.  Re-work the report. Group Success: Everyone in the group has given feedback for revisions. Accountability: Debrief: Share the report with the whole group for editing. What are the challenges to be dealt with to prepare this type of report? 86 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities GROUP ACTIVITIES FOR APPLICATION 87 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Read Maps / Charts Purpose: To use a map or chart to locate information. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 50 min Provide information and maps / charts. Guide activity Location positions on a map or chart Pairs, maps / charts 10 min Ensure correct positions Debrief activity Complete activity Identify individual process Pairs Activity – Read Maps / Charts Organizer: You must be able to read a map or chart to locate positions. Objective: Locate positions on a map or chart. Time: 60 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process:  Maps or charts, locations. Monitor and encourage participation. In pairs: Review the elements of map or chart reading.  Locate positions on the maps or chart. Individually:  Locate positions on the maps or chart.  Partner observes and times the procedure. They then give feedback and suggestions. Group Success: Everyone takes turns at locating and observing and timing. Accountability: Debrief: Each person can locate positions on the maps or charts. How did time pressure affect your performance? 88 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Prepare a Block Diagram Purpose: To identify the linkages between elements of a system. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 30 min Present system elements Guide activity Use a Block Diagram to depict how Small groups, paper, writing implements 10 min Comment on diagrams Debrief activity Share diagrams Discuss how process aided understanding Whole group Activity – Prepare a Block Diagram Organizer: Objective: Use a Block Diagram to depict how are linked. Time: 40 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process:  System information. Monitor and encourage participation. In small groups of three or four: Create your idea of how such a system would work.  Design a block diagram to show the operation of the system.  State the sequence of operation for Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the sequence. Accountability: Debrief: Compare diagrams with other participants and describe sequence. What element of the process is clearer to you now? 89 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Create a Flow Chart Purpose: To map out a flow chart. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Provide situation Guide activity Create flow chart to show sequence and decision loops Small groups 10 min Comment on flow chart Debrief activity Explain flow chart Describe group process Whole group Activity – Create a Flow Chart Organizer: Objective: Use a Flow Chart to depict the way in which . Time: 30 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Post-it notes, flipchart paper and markers, poster with basic Flow Chart symbols (decision, action, arrows, etc.). Monitor and encourage participation. Process:  In small group of three or four: Consider  Determine priorities of sequence on post-it notes.  State the sequence of operations for gathering the information.  Plot the sequence on the flipchart paper.  Show flow, decision trees and loops. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the strategies depicted. Accountability: other approaches. Debrief: Compare diagrams with other participants to determine advantages of What elements of other diagrams made the sequence clearer to you? 90 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Personal Planning Purpose: To identify the elements of personal plans. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 25 min Present situation Guide activity List elements of a personal plan Small group 10 min Comment on plans. Debrief activity Share personal plan Identify aids to process Whole group Activity – Personal Planning Organizer: Those who fail to plan are generally planning to fail. Objective: Make a list of things that you would do to prepare for a {for instance: any situation that takes personal planning, a trip, an emergency, a job interview, etc.}. Time: 35 minutes Techniques / Equipment: of ideas. Process: . Monitor and support participation and the exchange In group of three or four:  Exchange ideas on the following statement:  Write out a personal list of things to do.  Debrief ideas with whole class.  Students revise their own plans based on ideas from other groups. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the elements of the plans. Accountability: Debrief: Give copy of personal list to group members. How much of what you ended up with on your list was due to the ideas of others? 91 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Solve Problems Purpose: To practise applied problem solving of formulas. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Provide problem Identify data, unknowns, and formula Apply formula / solutions Small groups 10 min Comment on answers Debrief activity Explain answers and approach Describe group process Whole group Guide activity Activity – Solve Problems Organizer: Objective: Apply formulas to a set of data to solve problems. Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process:  Problem information. Monitor and encourage participation. In small group of three or four: Consider  Identify all of the known data.  Identify the unknown elements.  Identify any variables.  Apply the appropriate formula to the data set.  Verify the answer. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the process used. Accountability: approaches. Debrief: Compare answers with other participants and identify alternative What elements of other approaches made the problem clearer to you? 92 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Create a Classification Matrix Purpose: To analyze a whole using set criteria. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Provide information Guide activity Create a classification matrix for Pairs or small groups 10 min Comment on matrix. Debrief activity Present matrix Describe group process Whole group Activity – Classification Matrix Organizer: Objective: Relate data to two related sets of criteria. Time: 30 minutes Techniques / Equipment: criteria and classification headings and a sample matrix. Monitor and encourage participation. Process:  In pairs or groups of three or four: Organize a list of specific incidents into a matrix similar to the one below. Classification Classification Criteria Criteria Criteria  Discuss placement of data elements within the matrix before placement.  Agree on placement. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the classification strategies used. Accountability: Debrief: Identify acceptable placement of elements. Discuss the most frustrating aspect of the exercise. 93 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Propose Situations Purpose: To identify and document types of situations. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Identify elements of Guide activity Propose possible situations that might Small groups, flipchart, felt pens 10 min Collect and comment on situations. Debrief activity Identify how previous information fits Identify how understanding is increased Whole group Activity – Propose Situations Organizer: What types of situations might ? Objective: Propose possible situations that might . Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Personal experience, augment ideas to ensure comprehensive list. Flipchart, and felt pens. Monitor and encourage participation. Process: In pairs or triads:  Suggest various situations that might . In the whole group:  Share the possible situations from each group, rotating the response so that everyone contributes. Document on a flipchart.  Discuss ideas that are triggered by the proposed situations.  Use examples and documented information to expand on the ideas. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the proposed situations used. Accountability: Debrief: Identify how previous information fits into the expanded information. Identify how what was known already assists understanding of new materials. 94 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Develop Incidents Purpose: To create and expand on single incident situations. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Identify criteria for incidents Guide activity Create and develop incidents Small groups 10 min Collect and comment on incidents Debrief activity Present incidents Whole group Describe group process Activity – Create Incidents Organizer: Objective: Identify contexts for incident {for instance: a situation that could occur and which is related to the course content}. Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: participation. Process: Personal experience and written materials. Monitor and encourage Working in small groups of three or four using preset criteria:  Develop individual incidents from the preceding information in which a situation could occur.  Write them out a fully as possible in the time available. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the rationale for the incidents. Accountability: Share them with the other groups and explain them. Make comments on other incidents as to believability and stereotyping. Debrief: How easy would it be for these situations to occur? Could you imagine yourself in one? What thoughts did other people in your group share that expanded your understanding of these situations? 95 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Develop Timelines Purpose: To plot timelines based on various cases. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 25 min Identify possible timelines giving various scenarios through case studies Plot normal, delayed and accelerated timelines with developmental stages and milestones. Small groups, case studies 25 min Provide strategy templates and information Integrate development information with strategy development for planning. Small groups, case studies 10 min Collect comments Debrief activity Explain ideas discussed Describe group process Whole group Activity – Develop Timelines Organizer: Objective: Identify how normal, delayed and accelerated developmental stages of affect timelines. Time: 60 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Personal experience, developmental information, and case studies. Process: Working in small groups of three or four using developmental information and individual cases:  Identify whether this is normal, delayed and accelerated development.  Develop a complete developmental timeline from the given information.  Document the timeline as fully as possible in the time available. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the rationale for the timeline. Accountability: Share timelines with the other groups and explain them. Make comments on other timelines with regards to the cases. Debrief: How might these timelines play out if they in real life? What discussion occurred in your group that expanded your understanding of these timelines? 96 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Create Scenarios Purpose: To combine incidents into scenarios. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Identify criteria for scenarios Guide activity Develop complete scenarios with timelines Small groups 10 min Collect and comment on scenarios Debrief activity Discuss scenarios Describe group process Whole group Activity – Create Scenarios Organizer: Objective: Identify how individual incidents interact over time in . Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: incidents:  Personal experience and individual incidents. Working in small groups of three or four using preset criteria and individual Develop a complete scenario from the given information.  Identify a suitable timeline and how the incidents might interact.  Write them out a fully as possible in the time available. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the rationale for the scenario. Accountability: Share them with the other groups and explain them. Make comments on other scenarios with regards to flow and practicality. Debrief: How might these scenarios play out if they occurred in real life? How might you respond in one? What discussion occurred in your group that expanded your understanding of these situations? 97 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Operate Equipment (I) Purpose: To operate equipment safely and effectively. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 60 min Provide checklist and demonstration. Guide activity Operate safely and effectively Small groups, equipment 10 min Ensure checklists complete Debrief activity complete checklist Identify Individual Process Whole group Activity – Operate Equipment Organizer: You must be able to operate the equipment to use it effectively. Objective: Operate effectively. Time: 70 minutes Techniques / Equipment: participation. Process: Appropriate location, . Monitor and support In small groups of three or four:  Ensure all group members understand the safe operation of the equipment using the checklist as a guide.  Each group member operates the equipment.  Other group members observe operation referring to and completing the checklist.  Group discusses and strategizes operation possibilities.  Rotate roles until each member has operated and observed. Group Success: Everyone in the group participates in all roles and supports others. Accountability: All group members can demonstrate safe operations of . Checklists are completed. Debrief: Where are you on this matrix? Share this information with your group. 98 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Competency Matrix Not Competent Competent Not Conscious Conscious 1 2 can’t do it and don’t know can’t do it but know this 4 3 doing it naturally can do it and know this 99 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Discussion – Small Group – Application Purpose: To apply a concept effectively it is helpful to discuss it. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 15 min Pose question or outline situation Guide activity Exchange ideas and apply Small groups 10 min Collect application opinions / ideas Debrief activity Share information discussed Whole group Describe group process Activity – Discussion – Application Organizer: Objective: Exchange ideas and apply to new or unique situations. Time: 25 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process:  Monitor and support participation and the exchange of ideas. In groups of three or four: Exchange ideas on the following statement, presentation or reading. {for instance: how might a particular idea be applied or what could be done in a particular situation?} Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the ideas discussed. Accountability: Employ the concept in a new situation or to a new problem. Identify situations that employ the ideas on use. Debrief: Where and when could this application be useful? 100 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities GROUP ACTIVITIES FOR ANALYSIS 101 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Brainstorm Plus Purpose: To get a lot of concepts out so that they can be analyzed. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Identify elements of Guide activity Identify information known about Flipchart, felt pens, whole or small group 10 min Collect and comment on connections Debrief activity Identify how previous information fits Identify how understanding is increased Whole group Activity – Brainstorm and Analyze Organizer: This is a way to get a lot of ideas out about . Objective: Identify information known and ideas about and integrate it with new information {for instance: any complex content topic particularly where they may be preconceptions}. Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Personal experience, written information, flipchart, felt pens. Monitor and encourage participation. Augment ideas to ensure comprehensive list. Process: In pairs or triads:  Brainstorm the various types of that they know about. This is an all ideas are welcome, no analysis session.  Record the information. In the whole group:    Share the examples of from each group, rotating the response so that everyone contributes. Document on a flipchart. Discuss ideas that are triggered by the examples.  Use examples and documented information to expand on their ideas. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the ideas put forward. Accountability: Debrief: Identify how previous information fits into the expanded information. Identify how what was known already assists understanding of new materials. 102 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Pass a Problem Purpose: Quickly generate a wide range of ideas for a given situation and then order them in terms of perceived usefulness. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 5 min Provide as many problem situations as there are groups Meet group members and prepare to generate ideas small groups, problem situations 3 Guide activity min per round In 3 minute sections brainstorm as many divergent ideas on the problem as possible and write on paper. Insert into envelope and pass to next group small groups, paper, large envelopes 10 min Encourage groups Order one envelope’s information small groups, suggestions 10 min Complete accountability Debrief activity Achieve content objective Discuss aids to process Whole group Activity – name of the activity Organizer: The more divergent the ideas, the more paths are available for examination. Objective: Brainstorm a wide range of ideas for . Order them in terms of perceived usefulness (or other criteria). Pre Assessment: Are we already able to identify a wide range of divergent ideas. Time: 25 minutes plus 3 x the number of groups.. Techniques / Equipment: Problem situations, envelopes with the number of sheets of paper equal to the number of small groups. Explain process, monitor and support participation and the exchange of ideas. Process:  In pairs or triads: Brainstorm the most divergent and outrageous ideas for the problem in the envelope.  Repeat with the next envelope until the first envelope returns to you.  Order the items in the first/last envelope in terms of perceived usefulness (or other criteria). Group Success / Assessment: The group has been able to come up with outrageous ideas and then agree to an order of ideas on some basis. Accountability: Everyone in the group has contributed to the process. 103 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Debrief: ideas?. What helped you generate ideas? What hindered you? How did you order the Summary: This is a techniques of mental exercise to get into the frame of mind for deliberate idea generation. 104 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Compare Systems Purpose: To compare systems or process information so that it can be analyzed. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 15 min Provide chart and information Guide activity Compare and contrast categories of information Pairs, chart & information 10 min Collect tables Debrief activity Create a table Whole group Describe how ideas were shared Activity – Compare Organizer: The information in is both related and different from the information in . Objective: Prepare a table and compare types of information. Time: 25 minutes Techniques / Equipment: and the exchange of ideas. Process:  Table blank and information. Monitor and support participation In pairs: Find the similarities and differences between .  Using the following table fill in the information and then compare categories. Information System System System Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the categories. Accountability: Share the comparisons and contrasts with the whole group. Debrief: In what ways did comparisons clarify the material? 105 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Differentiate Situations Purpose: To examine multiple ways in which situations may be analyzed. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 15 min Set out situation Differentiate between Small groups 10 min Collect examples of difference Debrief activity Describe differences Describe aids to group process Whole group Activity – Differentiate Organizer: Given a situation which could be described in various ways, how do you know which one is correct? Objective: Differentiate between {for instance: a vehicle owner and a vehicle mechanic dealing with a vehicle, a counsellor and a police officer dealing with a troubled person, etc.}. Time: 25 minutes Techniques / Equipment: situations for differentiating, flipchart, pens. Monitor and support participation and the exchange of ideas. Process: In groups of three or four:   Discuss the situation and determine which of the categories match the situation. Describe in clear, non technical terms how you could help a person grasp the difference between . Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the differences. Accountability: Using Numbered Heads Together have a member of each group report on their method of describing the difference. Debrief: How would you compare the feelings in your group about this to someone with a professional involvement, such as {for instance: the participant and the people in the various occupations relating to the situation discussed}? 106 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Classify Purpose: To analyze elements so that classifications can be applied. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 15 min Specify material and provide basis for classification Analyze elements and assign to appropriate classification Pairs or small groups, elements. 10 min Ensure accuracy. Debrief activity Explain classification system Describe group process Whole group Activity – Classify Situations Organizer: Objective: Classify criteria, situations, or objects. {for instance: criteria for completion of a project, types of situations, or objects or systems, or processes} Time: 25 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Lists of items (could also be cut into strips and placed in envelopes). Provide support for and encourage participation in working groups. Present information and a framework basis for classification. Process: In pairs or small groups of three or four:  Organize material into groupings {for instance: 3 columns (or more), as below.} X Y Z  Discuss the rationale for your classification. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the classifications. Accountability: alternatives. Debrief: Describe organization of your group’s materials. Identify other How do other identified alternatives change your point of view? 107 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Analyze Audiotape Purpose: To practise analyzing incidents using audio information. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Play audiotape Guide activity Identify appropriate and inappropriate responses to given situations Small groups, audiotape, tape player 10 min Ensure appropriate response Debrief activity Report on responses Describe group process Whole group Activity – Analysis of Audiotape Organizer: Objective: Review an incident on audiotape and critique the response. Time: 30 minutes Techniques / Equipment: exchange of ideas. Process:  Audiotape, tape player, Monitor and support participation and the In small groups of two or three: Listen to the for yourself using input from others. Time: 25 minutes Techniques / Equipment: A situation, each participant’s personal point of view on the issue. Monitor and support participation and the exchange of ideas. Process: In pairs:  Peer review , looking for how they were different. Group Success: Both people can explain the differences in the issues. Accountability: Debrief: Have selection of pairs report on differences. How prepared am I for this situation? 134 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Analyze Reports Purpose: To analyze the elements of reports. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 15 min Distribute samples of a report on Analyze the elements of a report on Pairs 15 min Answer questions, collect comments Debrief activity Identify the most difficult elements of the report Whole group Activity – Analyze Reports Organizer: Objective: Analyze required reports to identify elements and their application. Time: 30 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process:  Sample Reports. Monitor and encourage participation. In pairs, using report samples: Identify the need for the elements of the report.  Analyze the elements of the report for their application. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the elements of the report. Accountability: Debrief: Share personal understanding of elements with other groups. What were the most difficult elements of the report? 135 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Analyze Case Studies Purpose: To analyze case studies or other materials to predict possible outcomes. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 30 min Present case studies Guide activity Present actual results Analyze case studies to identify trends and predict results Small groups, case studies 10 min Collect and comment on analysis and prediction Debrief activity Share analysis and prediction Identify group process Whole group Activity – Analyze Case Studies Organizer: Objective: Analyze case studies to identify trends and predict results. Time: 40 minutes Techniques / Equipment: participation. Process: Case studies (or other indicator materials). Monitor and encourage Working in small groups of three or four, using case studies:  Track case studies through the various stages of development.  Analyze the elements that interact within the situation.  Predict what might happen . Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the rationale for the prediction. Accountability: How committed are you to the group decision (5-1 scale)? Record commitment levels and predictions. Share opinion with other groups. Compare analysis with actual outcome. Debrief: see? Compare predictions with actual results. What surprises or confirmations do you 136 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Develop Strategies using Case Studies Purpose: To use case studies or other materials as a basis to develop strategies. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Present case studies Guide activity Present actual results Use case studies to develop appropriate strategies Small groups, case studies 20 min Collect and comment on strategies Debrief activity Share strategies Whole group Identify group process Activity – Develop Strategies using Case Studies Organizer: Objective: Use case studies to develop appropriate strategies. Time: 40 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process:  Case studies, text materials. Monitor and encourage participation. Working in small groups of three or four, using case studies: Identify critical elements of case studies.  Develop appropriate strategies to apply to the situations. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the rationale for the strategies chosen. Accountability: situations. Debrief: Share strategies with other groups. Compare strategies with actual What resources will you need to apply these strategies? 137 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Prioritize Situations Purpose: To prioritize a number of situations using set criteria. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 30 min Play audiotape Identify appropriate and inappropriate responses to given situations Small groups, audiotape, tape player 10 min Ensure appropriate priority. Assign appropriate priority to information Discuss personal certainty Whole group Guide activity Debrief activity {for instance: The example here is for emergency calls, but it could also be steps in a process, project development, meetings, etc.} Activity – Prioritize Situations Organizer: Being able to quickly assign priority to a is a critical skill. Objective: Listen to on audiotape and assign appropriate priorities. Time: 40 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Audiotapes, tape player, and incidents. Monitor and encourage participation and the exchange of ideas. Process: In small groups of two or three:  Listen to audiotapes of .  Discuss the calls and assign them a priority. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the rationale for the priority. Accountability: chosen. Describe various possible priorities and give reasons why they were Debrief: How certain were you about your priority assignments on a scale of 1 (very certain) to 5 (very uncertain)? Why? 138 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities List / Refer / Clarify Purpose: To utilize knowledgeable sources to verify understanding. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 30 min Refer to information from Guide activity List the elements of Refer to knowledgeable sources Small groups paper, writing implements 10 min Comment on information Debrief activity Clarify information Discuss aids to process Whole group Activity – List / Refer / Clarify Organizer: Using the information from , identify a logical and useful order for the materials. Objective: it. Identify personal understanding of information on and expand on Time: 40 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Paper and writing implements, information from the participant brainstorm on to connect to . . Fill in information not covered by participants. Monitor and support participation and the exchange of ideas. Process: Individually:  List in order the with respect to how familiar they personally are with it. In groups of three or four:  Share lists with the focus on looking for others with knowledge about they are unfamiliar with.  Refer to this more knowledgeable resource and listening to their explanations. Group Success: Everyone in the group can identify what they know and what they don’t know. Accountability: Have groups report on that they are still unsure and record on a list. See if others in the class can help with information on these items. Debrief: How did you learn? How did members of your group and the larger group assist your learning? 139 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Structured Academic Controversy Purpose: To elaborate on and vocalize different sides of a controversy. This is different than a debate where only one side is taken and a winner is often declared. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 45 min Present reference documents Guide activity Identify and explore various aspects of Small groups, reference documents 30 min Act as referee and timekeeper Present both sides of an issue Discuss how process affects concepts and ideas Whole group Debrief activity {For instance: the following assumes a public controversy but this could be any content related situation that has clear sides with lines drawn.} Activity – Structured Academic Controversy Organizer: There are increasingly polarized positions being assumed by the public in the face of . Objective: Identify and explore various aspect of . Time: 75 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Position reference documents. Describe the process and leave the instructions on the overhead or write out on the flipchart. Debrief the individual groups with the whole class. Monitor and support participation and the exchange of ideas. Process: Start with groups of four, and then have the groups pair off:  Using the reference documentation answer the questions .     Prepare in pairs (one pair yes, one pair no). Discuss with other pair. Reverse positions with other pair. Repeat discussion process.  Share experiences with the larger group. Group Success: Everyone in the group participates in all roles and supports others. Accountability: their presentations. Each participant is able to move from one position to the other position in Debrief: What happened with respect to your perception of through the discussion? 140 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Discussion – Small Group – Synthesis Purpose: To join concepts and elements into a whole picture and to encourage lateral thinking about a situation. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Pose question or outline situation Guide activity Exchange ideas and synthesize with Small groups 10 min Comment on synthesis Explain synthesis of information Describe group process Whole group Debrief activity {for instance: the effects of one person’s actions on a neighborhood, how the California Environmental Protection Act affects consumer goods in Canada, NAFTA on the global economy, etc.} Activity – Discussion – Synthesis Organizer: Objective: Exchange ideas and synthesize with . Time: 30 minutes Techniques / Equipment: personal experience with . Monitor and support participation and the exchange of ideas. Process: In groups of three or four:  Exchange ideas on the following statement, presentation or reading  Synthesize the material to identify a whole system. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the whole system. Accountability: Identify the best application from your group. Debrief: What other connections can be made with the synthesized information and other similar situations? How could you employ the concept in a new situation or to a new problem? 141 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Discussion – Small Group – Evaluation Purpose: To evaluate and provide rationale for chosen solutions to a given situations. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Pose question, give situation Evaluate possible answers and rationale that apply to the question in a given situation Small group 10 min Comment on ideas Debrief activity Share answers and rationale Describe group process Whole group Guide activity Activity – Discussion – Evaluation Organizer: Objective: question >. Identify and evaluate possible answers including a rationale to  Evaluate how they could be applied in a given situation. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the applications. Accountability: Randomly report which answers appear to most useful in this situation. Debrief: thoughts? What points were brought out in the discussion that helped to focus your 142 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities GROUP ACTIVITIES FOR INTERACTION AND PRACTISE 143 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Dialogue Purpose: message. To develop dialogues that are reflective of the impact of the verbal and underlying Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Present situations Guide activity Develop dialogues. Identify implications of verbal and underlying messages. Pairs, situations 10 min Comment on information. Debrief activity Share your group information Describe group process Whole group Activity – Dialogue Organizer: Objective: Imagine and develop dialogues that could be used for various . Time: 30 minutes Techniques / Equipment: exchange of ideas. Situations for dialogue. Monitor and support participation and the Process:   Form pairs by numbering off. Identify some verbal messages you might find yourself using in the following situations.   Discuss the implications of these messages both verbal and underlying.  Refine your dialogue to take these implications into account. Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the final dialogue elements. Accountability: Debrief: Share your group information with the large group. How could you adapt your messages for better communications? 144 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Interact with a Guest Speaker Purpose: attendance. To promote positive interaction with guest speakers and to avoid passive Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 60 min Introduce guest speaker Ask pertinent questions Whole group 15 min Guide activity Identify and write a report on the main ideas presented Small groups 10 min Collect reports Debrief activity Hand in reports Describe group process Whole group Monitor Activity Activity – Interact with a Guest Speaker Organizer: Guest speakers from industry are vital links to the real world. They hold their positions through competence and expertise in their particular area and are rich sources of information and opinion. Objective: Identify and report on the main ideas presented on . Time: 85 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Guest Speaker with extensive experience in . Monitor and support participation and the exchange of ideas. Process: Individually:  Listen and take notes on the most important points.  Make eye contact during the presentation.  Ask clarifying questions. In pairs:  Read and compare notes on presentation by the guest speaker.  Revise notes to identify the most important elements of presentation. Group Success: Both people have given feedback for revisions. Accountability: Debrief: you? Hand in copy of your revised notes to the instructor. What insights did your partner share that clarified any part of the presentation for 145 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Interactive Practise Purpose: To practise an active skill that incorporates immediate feedback and analysis by fellow learners as well as from the instructor. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Present situations Set groups Prepare to Practise with appropriate situations. Pairs or triads, skill information 10 min Guide activity Observe application practise. Practise with appropriate situations. Pairs or triads 10 min Assess ability to obtain and refer information Observe Pairs or triads 10 min Focus feedback session Give feedback to partner on observations Pairs or triads 10 min Set new groups Observe application practise Practise with appropriate situations Pairs or triads 10 min Focus feedback session Give feedback to partner on observations Pairs or triads 10 min Focus debriefing Identify strengths and areas for improvement Pairs or triads 10 min Debrief process of activity Describe group process Whole group Activity – Interactive Practise Organizer: Objective: Practise using appropriate situations. Time: 80 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: practise situations. Monitor and support participation. Working in pairs or triads and using the following situations:  Each person takes the role of in turn.  Ensure the is aware of the actions and information that is crucial to use and/or obtain in each situation. Utilize techniques to ensure the appropriate information is obtained and actions initiated.  146 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities  Observer takes notes and gives feedback on how the situation was dealt with.  Everyone discusses how else it could be done.  Process is repeated until everyone has been in every role. Group Success: Everyone in the group participates in all roles and supports others. Accountability: Identify which techniques appear to most useful in these situations? Which ones are the easiest to use? Which ones need more work? Debrief: harder? How did it feel to take on the different roles? What made it easy? What made it Situations:    {For instance: This format can be used to practise any type of skill including customer interactions, operation of equipment, following a process, etc. A sample of Call Taking follows using pairs of pairs.} 147 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Interactive Practise – Call Taking Purpose: To practise Call Taking that incorporates immediate feedback and analysis by fellow learners as well as from the instructor. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Set incidents for practise Set groups Prepare to practise call taking with supplied incidents Quads, skill information 10 min Guide activity Observe application practise Obtain critical information from Quads callers, make calls 10 min Assess ability to obtain and refer information Observe caller and call taking Quads 10 min Focus feedback session Give feedback to partner on observations Quads 10 min Set new groups Observe application practise. Practise call assessment with incidents Quads 10 min Focus feedback session Give feedback to partner on observations Quads 10 min Focus debriefing Identify strengths and areas for improvement Quads 10 min Debrief process of activity Describe group process Whole group Activity – Simulations – Call Taking Organizer: This is a chance for participants to work with safe and realistic situations. Objective: Practise calling, call taking, and observation, with giving and receiving feedback. Time: 80 minutes Techniques / Equipment: support participation. Process:    Incidents, phones, headsets, and observation sheets. Monitor and In pairs of pairs (quads): one pair will consist of a caller and an observer of the caller. one pair will consist of a call taker and an observer of the call taker. The call is made and taken realistically by the caller and call taker using the information in the incidents and the skills, knowledges and attitudes taught. 148 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities  Information will be documented on a written form or on a CAD system.    Information will be passed on to an appropriate agency by the call taker as necessary. The observers will observe the process without interfering. The observers will provide positive written and verbal feedback to their partner after each incidents using the elements of feedback basics.  Pairs of pairs will discuss problems that arise out of the incident and strategize around different approaches.  Each pairs will change roles between themselves and repeat the above process.  Pairs will then partner with a new pair and reverse roles (the caller pair becomes the call taker pair and vice versa). Group Success: Everyone in the group participates in all roles and supports others. Accountability: Positive feedback will be given from the observer to the other partner after each incident. Share strategies for dealing with the problems that could arise in the incidents. Debrief: What was the best part of your practise with your partners? Identify strengths and areas for improvement. Incidents:    149 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities GROUP ACTIVITIES FOR REFLECTION 151 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Reflective Practise – Observation Purpose: To practise observing from diverse positions. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Assign roles and situation to be observed Guide activity Observe from a specific role Small groups 20 min Gather ideas and comments Debrief activity Share observations Discuss importance Whole group {For instance: The following activity is around observation from the point of view of diversity but you could also use observation from various points of view such as work functions or positions within an organization.} Activity – Diversity Observation Organizer: Objective: Observe from a specific role. Time: 40 minutes Techniques / Equipment: 3x5 cards, flipchart paper, markers, and masking tape. Assign to each participant (or pair of participants) a human role that may or may not be in existence in the institution. Create profiles of specific roles to fit the size of the group and demographic of the institution. Roles should include elements of race, colour, ancestry, place of origin, religion, marital status, family status, physical or mental disability, sex, sexual orientation, age, or political affiliation {for instance: a Indo-Canadian male, 18 years old with English as a second language, or a German female, 68 years old who uses a wheelchair}. Process: In small groups:  The participants leave the room and walk through the building and surrounding area looking for how the role they have assumed is reflected in the environment (i.e. on posters, in the hallways, on monitors, by activities they see, etc.).  When the participants return, ask them to either verbally report their findings or post their findings on flipchart. In the large group discuss the following questions:      How is your role reflected in the environment? Who is in this role within this institution? What privileges does your role have or not have in the classroom or workplace? How does this affect influence in the classroom or workplace? Is privilege situational? 152 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities  What is the relationship between power, privilege and perceived roles? Group Success: Everyone in the group can explain the point of view of others. Accountability: Participate and give feedback. Debrief: What did you see that you haven’t seen or looked at before? How did you feel in a role that is different from your usual role? 153 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Reflective Practise – Questions or Situations Purpose: To encourage reflection on content questions or situations. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Pose question Guide activity Reflect on a question or situation of Think-PairShare 10 min Gather ideas and comments Debrief activity Share ideas Discuss importance Whole group Activity – Reflective Practise on a Question Organizer: Objective: Reflect on a question about Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: Monitor and support participation and the exchange of ideas. Using the following question or situation. Individually:  Reflect on the question or situation. In pairs:  Share your thoughts and listen to their thoughts. Group Success: Both people have voiced their thoughts. Accountability: Debrief: materials. Share your ideas with the larger group. Reflect on the importance of in the context of the other course 154 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Reflective Practise – Response to Change Purpose: To reflect on personal response to change. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Introduce topic Guide activity Reflect on how is personally understood. Think-PairShare 10 min Gather ideas and comments Debrief activity Comment on perceptions Discuss how emotional response affects actions. whole group Activity – Reflective Practise – Response to Change Organizer: Objective: Reflect on how emotional response to is personally understood. Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: Monitor and support participation and the exchange of ideas. Using the following situation. Scenario: {for instance: the loss of a friend, reorganization of the workplace, a new member of the family, etc.}. Individually:  Reflect on your personal understanding and relationship to this situation. In pairs:  Share your thoughts and listen to the other person’s thoughts. Group Success: Both people have voiced their thoughts. Accountability: Debrief: planning. Share perceptions with the larger group. Reflect on how your understanding of affects your personal 155 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Reflective Practise – Identify Personal Bias Purpose: To reflect on personal biases in our relations with people and situations. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Introduce topic Guide activity Reflect on how is personally understood Think-PairShare 10 min Gather ideas and comments Debrief activity Comment on perceptions Discuss how perceptions affect interactions Whole group Activity – Reflective Practise – Personal Bias Organizer: Personal bias affects how we relate to . Objective: Reflect on how is personally understood. Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Monitor and support participation and the exchange of ideas. Process: Using the following situation. Scenario: Individually:  Reflect on your personal understanding and relationship to this situation. In pairs:  Share your thoughts and listen to the other person’s thoughts. Group Success: Both people have voiced their thoughts. Accountability: Debrief: others. Share perceptions with the larger group. Reflect on how your understanding of affects your interaction with 156 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Reflective Practise – Effect of Assumptions Purpose: actions. To reflect on how we make assumptions and how these assumptions affect our Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Introduce topic Guide activity Reflect on how your personal assumptions affect your response to . Think-PairShare 10 min Gather ideas and comments Debrief activity Comment on perceptions Discuss how perceptions affect interactions Whole group Activity – Reflective Practise about Assumptions Organizer: What assumptions do you bring to the discussion on ? Objective: Reflect on personal assumptions about . Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: exchange of ideas. Process: Personal knowledge. Monitor and support participation and the Individually:  Reflect on your assumptions about . In pairs:  Share your thoughts and listen to the other person’s thoughts.  Discuss how these assumptions affect your actions. Group Success: Both people have voiced their thoughts. Accountability: Debrief: Share your ideas with the larger group. Reflect on how assumptions impact on your response to . 157 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities GROUP ACTIVITIES TO COMPLEMENT PROJECTS 158 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Set Criteria – Project or Exercise Purpose: To ensure that the participants have a clear picture of what is required to complete a project or exercise successfully. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Pose question “What will a good project be like?” Guide activity Set clear criteria for assessment of Small groups, whole group, I charts 10 min Ensure appropriate criteria Debrief activity Agree on criteria Discuss how Process affects outcomes Whole group Activity – Set Criteria – Project or Exercise Organizer: To be clear on what is necessary to complete a project, it is necessary to be clear on what criteria will be used to assess the final product. Objective: Set clear criteria for assessment of . Pre-Assessment: What will the criteria for success be for this session? Time: 30 minutes Techniques / Equipment: reasonable criteria. Process: I charts, project information, samples and guidance to form In groups of three or four:  Use an I chart to answer the question “What would a completely effective, 100% final product or exercise look, sound and feel like?”  Discuss the ideas to develop shared meaning within the group. Group Success: Everyone in the group has given input. Accountability: Share each group’s information with the larger group and develop a single criteria for assessment. Debrief: project? How does a clear criteria affect the way that you will approach this exercise or Summary We now have a complete criteria for the next project. 159 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities “I” Charts help us see better looks like sounds like feels like 160 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Report on Field Trips Purpose: To frame a field trip in a way that will encourage interactive analysis. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 170 min Arrange tour of a facility Guide activity Explore the of a large-scale industry Pairs, 10 min Collect and comment on reports. Debrief activity Produce a report Whole group Describe group process Activity – Field Trip Organizer: A guided tour of is intended to allow participants to develop an overview of this industry. Objective: Explore the of a large-scale industry or an agency. Time: 180 minutes Techniques / Equipment: participation. Process: Tour of a facility or an agency. Monitor and encourage In pairs:  Take and compare notes on elements that appear important.  Identify the critical aspects of for this location.  Analyze how this industry or agency allocates resources to . Group Success: Both people have given input for the report. Accountability: Produce a report that discusses the critical aspects of in this location and how this industry has allocated resources. Debrief: How did your partner’s observations differ from your own? In what way was this helpful to your understanding of the site? 161 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Use a Model for Assessment Purpose: To apply an assessment model to case studies. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Present Assessment Model for Discuss current knowledge and gaps of how to complete assessment process Small groups, whole group 10 min Deliver new information on identified gaps. Give case studies Discuss case studies in relation to application of assessment model Small groups, case studies, text materials 10 min Guide process Collect information Identify differences in application of model and what else needs to be done to bridge assessment gaps Small groups, whole group Activity – Use a Model for Assessment Organizer: How many are familiar with the assessment model from ? Objective: Discuss case studies in relation to application of assessment model. Time: 40 minutes Techniques / Equipment: support participation. Process: Case studies, Assessment model, activity sheets. Monitor and In pairs:  Identify the elements of the assessment model.  Discuss how the assessment model would be applied in a variety of situations.  Discuss how differences in those being assessed impacts on the assessment. Group Success: Both people can describe the application methods. Accountability: Share this information with other groups. Debrief: How did your partner add to your knowledge and the ability to identify how various differences impact on the assessment? 162 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Use Resource Materials Purpose: To encourage the use of location specific resource materials. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 40 min Present resources and activity Guide activity Use local resource materials quickly Pairs, resource materials 10 min Collect activity sheets accountability Debrief activity Locate information Complete activity sheets Discuss aids to process Pairs Activity – Use Resource Materials Organizer: How many are familiar with resource materials from ? Objective: Describe the information found in a variety of local reference sources. Time: 50 minutes Techniques / Equipment: participation. Process:  Reference sources, activity sheets. Monitor and support In pairs: Identify the types of resources available.  Discuss where particular information may be found.  Complete activity sheets using the appropriate reference sources. Group Success: Both people have given feedback for revisions. Accountability: Debrief: project? Pair check each other’s activity before handing it in. How did your partner add to your knowledge and the ability to complete the 163 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Research Information Purpose: To support appropriate research and citation techniques. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 45 min Identify topic for research Guide activity Document citations using appropriate formats Pairs, library resources 10 min Comment on formats Debrief activity Compare formats with others Discuss challenges whole group Assignment – Research Organizer: Objective: Find information on and document it correctly. Time: 55 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process:  Library resources. Monitor and support participation. Working in pairs: Given an assigned topic, use the library and other resources to research the appropriate citations.  Write them out in the appropriate manner. Group Success: Both people have given feedback for revisions. Accountability: to the instructor. Compare formats with other pairs and make corrections. Submit material Debrief: What were the challenges to be dealt with to complete the assignment? How do we celebrate our success? 164 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Summarize Purpose: To practise summarizing skills. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 15 min Provide material focus Reflect on material, determine essential elements, summarize Pairs 10 min Collect summaries Hand in summary material Discuss how process affects concepts and ideas Whole group Debrief activity Activity – Summarize Organizer: Objective: Reflect on material and make judgments about relative importance of elements Time: 25 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Presentation, written or research information to provide framework information, or provide content references, for participants. Provide criteria for participant decisions on what is essential. Monitor and support participation. Process: Individually:  Reflect on the presentation.  Create a written summary of the essential points of the presentation. In groups of three or four:   Share summaries within the group. Representatives of each group take turns presenting their essential points to the class. Assure that all points are covered.  Adjust individual summaries on the basis of other summaries. Group Success: Everyone in the group has given input. Accountability: Hand in material to the instructor for review. Debrief: Reflect on the process of identifying essential elements. This framework will be used to reflect on specific incidents. 165 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Make Referrals Purpose: To link services with needs and make appropriate referrals. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 30 min Identify the elements of the referral process Explain how referrals are completed for people in need in specific situations Small groups 20 min Collect information Debrief activity Share information on referrals Whole group Activity – Make Referrals Organizer: Objective: Identify services and link needs with available services. Time: 50 minutes Techniques / Equipment: participation. Process:  Community and other resources. Monitor and support Working in pairs: Identify services that are available for a variety of needs.  Link the needs with available and appropriate services.  Make appropriate referrals. Group Success: Both people agree on the referrals. Accountability: make adjustments. Debrief: Compare suggested referrals with other pairs, explaining rationale, and What were the challenges to be dealt with to complete the referrals? 166 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Review an Assignment Purpose: To clarify expectations on assignments. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Clarify assignment requirements Ask questions about unclear parts of the assignment Whole group 10 min Explain requirements Clarify expectations for assignment Describe assessment of ability Whole group Debrief activity Activity – Review an Assignment Organizer: An assignment needs to be understood before it can be completed. Objective: Clarify expectations for the current assignment. Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: necessary. Process:  Assignment outline and/or marking sheet. Instructor clarifies as In formal groups within the whole group: Identify reasons for the assignment and general expectations.  Review documents and ask clarifying questions. Group Success: Everyone in the group agrees on their understanding of the assignment. Accountability: Random students are asked to describe how they understand of the assignment. Bring individual assignment designs to the next session for review. Debrief: assignment? How well do you think that you and your group can meet the requirements of this 167 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Develop Interview Questions Purpose: To develop respectful interview questions to gather information. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Present assignment Develop a list of interview questions to gather information Formal groups 20 min Moderate the presentations Cross check questions for usefulness Present group questions Comment on questions Formal groups 10 min Ask clarifying questions. Identify questions that are respectful and designed to elicit information Whole group 10 min May be assigned for out of class time Collect question lists Refine personal question list Individual 10 min Debrief activity Identify ways that your group helped Small groups Assignment – Develop Interview Questions Organizer: Objective: Develop respectful interview questions to gather information. Time: 70 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Assignment that requires information to be gathered from people. Monitor and support participation and the exchange of ideas. Process:   In formal groups of three or four: Use the assignment to identify categories of information to be acquired. Develop a series of questions to acquire the needed information.  Identify who will be asked the questions.  Phrase the questions in a respectful way intended to elicit a positive response.  Be prepared to change the questions as necessary. With the whole group:  Present and comment on each other’s draft questions. Group Success: Everyone in the group has given feedback for revisions. 168 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Accountability: Develop a series of questions that you can use. Submit the signed list to the instructor. Use the questions to acquire information. Debrief: What were the challenges to be dealt with to develop the questions? What comments from others helped? 169 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Develop a Plan Purpose: To develop a plan using input from a group of stakeholders. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 60 min May be done out of class. Identify plan topic and criteria Develop a plan for Formal groups 60 min Moderate the presentations Cross check for accuracy Present group plans Assess plans by criteria Formal groups 20 min Collect items indicated for inclusion in single plan Identify the portions for inclusion in the single plan Whole group 20 min Ask clarifying questions Refine single plan. Whole group Assignment – Develop a Plan Organizer: Objective: Develop a plan for . Time: 160 minutes Techniques / Equipment: A variety of resources, preset criteria. Monitor and support participation and the exchange of ideas. Process: In formal groups of three or four:  Use the appropriate resources to research the information.  Develop a plan for , using a standard format.  Be prepared to change the plan as necessary. With the whole group:  Present and comment on each other’s draft plans.  Synthesize a single plan for the whole group. Group Success: Everyone in the group has given feedback for revisions. Accountability: Submit the signed plan to the instructor. Exercise the plan for viability. Debrief: What were the challenges to be dealt with to complete the plan? How did we work well together? 170 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Exercise a Plan Purpose: To ensure that a developed plan is usable and effective. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 90 min Cross-check for accurate assessments Guide activity Exercise the plan Complete self-assessment Assess other groups Formal groups, whole group reality environment 20 min Collect final plan Revise the plan with the whole group Whole group 10 min Debrief activity Identify group process Whole group Assignment – Exercise a Plan Organizer: Now that you have a plan you need to find out if it will work under pressure. Objective: Exercise a plan for . Time: 140 minutes Techniques / Equipment: A completed plan for , preset criteria, reality environment, instructor to cross-check for accurate assessment. Monitor and support participation. Process: In formal groups of five or six:  Implement the plan in a reality environment.  Assess the effectiveness of the plan by your group.  Compare assessments with observer groups.  Act as assessing observers for other groups. With the whole group:  Revise a single plan for the whole group for maximum effectiveness. Group Success: Everyone in the group has given feedback for revisions. Accountability: Use preset criteria to assess own and other groups’ exercise. Debrief: What were the challenges to be dealt with to objective assess yourselves and other groups. How do you feel about your performance? How do we celebrate our success? 171 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Make a Presentation Purpose: To support a presentation before it is made. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 20 min Set up situation for the preparation of the outline Identify elements necessary to make a presentation outline Small group 330 min Identify project teams Guide project Develop a presentation. Revise with feedback Formal groups var. Resources 60 min Identify areas of process to document Document the group process Formal groups 60 min Review the presentation Make a presentation to a group Formal groups, target group 10 min Debrief activity Identify group process Whole group Assignment – Presentation Organizer: Objective: Develop and make a presentation on to a group. Time: 1-8 hours (depending on materials and scope of presentation) Techniques / Equipment: Library and community resources, an assigned topic, and a target group. Monitor content and support participation. Objective 1: Prepare an outline for a presentation on to a community group. Time: 20 minutes Process 1:    In small groups of four or five: Identify elements necessary to make a presentation outline. Research the appropriate information on . Identify the needs and understanding of a specific target group.  Create an outline for the presentation that will effectively deliver this information to a specific target group. Group Success: Everyone in the group has given feedback for revisions. Accountability: Hand in outline signed by all members of the group to instructor. Document the group process. 172 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Debrief: What were the best sources of information? What did you learn in the process of developing the outline? How well is your group working together? Objective 2: Present the revised activity to a specific group. Time: 2 – 7 hours (depending on the scope of the presentation) Process 2: In small groups of four or five:  Revise the outline created in Objective 1 after receiving instructor feedback.  Identify a community group to which you will make a presentation on .  Use the revised outline to create a presentation for this group. Group Success: Everyone in the group has been involved in developing and making the presentation. Accountability: Document the group process. Make the presentation to the group. Receive feedback from the group. Debrief: What did you learn from each other about collaborating on the presentation process? How will you celebrate? Debrief: How did the group use the information to produce the presentation? What criteria did the group use to decide the best presentation methods? 173 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Presentation Feedback Give examples Full participation by all members ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Clear, concise, accurate and informative ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Use of pictures and/or diagrams ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Interesting for the learners (creative and entertaining) ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Interactive with audience ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Audio/Visual ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Evaluation:  Did the learners learn? How do you see this? ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ 174 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities GROUP ACTIVITIES TO ACQUIRE FEEDBACK 175 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Identify Key Points Purpose: Time To ensure that material is understood and integrated. Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 5 min Ask for key points Guide activity Identify key points of Individual; 3x5 cards 4 min Form pairs Share one point Pairs 1 min Collect information) Hand in written materials Whole group 10 min Consider information Whole group Compile and respond to points (next class) Activity – Identify Key Points Organizer: It is necessary to identify what each person has gained. Objective: Identify key points of . Time: Up to 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: 3x5 cards. Monitor and encourage participation. Individually:  On 3x5 cards write down 6 – 10 key points from today’s material. In pairs:  Share one point from each person’s card. Group Success: Both people have written cards. Accountability: Debrief: Hand the card to the instructor before you leave. Next session, go over the main points and fill in any missing elements. 176 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Classroom Research Purpose: Time To get feedback on participant understanding. Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 5 min Pose questions Guide activity Identify elements of Individual; 3x5 cards 4 min Form pairs Share one point. Pairs 1 min Collect information Hand in written materials Whole group 10 min Consider information Whole group Compile and respond to points (next class) Activity – Classroom Research Organizer: The instructor needs to know what the learner has understood from the lesson. Objective: Answer a question about . Time: Up to 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Process: 3x5 cards. Monitor and encourage participation. Individually on 3x5 cards write down: The most important point. The most obscure point. One question that remains. In pairs:  Share one point from each person’s card. Group Success: Both people have written cards. Accountability: Debrief: Hand the card to the instructor before you leave. Next session, go over the main points and fill in missing elements. 177 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities One Minute Paper Purpose: Time To assess current understanding of important material. Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment Guide activity Identify points thought to be important Individual, paper, writing implements 1 min Collect information Hand in written materials Whole group 10 min Consider information Whole group 4 min Pose question on material Compile and respond to points (next class) Activity – One Minute Paper Organizer: Objective: Organize learning and identify points thought to be important. Time: 5 minutes in class, 10 minutes for follow up next class. Techniques / Equipment: and the exchange of ideas. Paper and writing implements. Monitor and support participation Process: Take one minute to write on a piece of paper that will be handed in your comments on the following: In pairs:  Share one point from each person’s paper. Group Success: Both people have written papers. Accountability: Debrief: Hand in paper to instructor Next session, go over the main points and fill in missing elements. 178 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Summarize Purpose: To review previous information. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 15 min Guide Summary activity Summarize what is known, and not known at this point Small groups, whole group Activity – Summarize Organizer: is important to the next section of the course. Objective: material. Identify current knowledge and change in personal knowledge by reviewing Time: 15 minutes Techniques / Equipment: the exchange of ideas. Process:  Material previously covered. Monitor and support participation and In groups of three or four: Summarize the points that have been made by the group during the day. This will include: a) Knowledge that they have identified that they have when they came in. b) Knowledge gaps that existed when they came in. c) Knowledge that they have filled in during the day. d) Knowledge gaps that still exist. Group Success: Everyone has identified all four elements of knowledge and gaps. Accountability: Debrief: Give information to instructor Instructor will identify:  Which gaps will be filled during the rest of the course.  Which gaps will be covered in the self-study materials. Which materials will be self-researched by the participants in another setting. 179 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities RSQC2 Purpose: To review previous information. This technique is adapted from Classroom Assessment Techniques by Thomas A. Angelo and K. Patricia Cross (1993) Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA, USA. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Guide activity Apply RSQC2 to Small groups Activity – RSQC2 Organizer: is important to the next section of the course. Objective: Check for understanding and review . Time: 10 minutes Techniques / Equipment: the exchange of ideas. Process: Material previously covered. Monitor and support participation and In groups of three or four: Use the following sequence to go over  Recall – the main points of the material, individually     Summarize – these points into sentences in their group Question – any ideas that seem unclear (Group Success – everyone responds) Connect – the summary statements to the whole course content (Accountability) Comment – on feelings about the material (Debrief) (could also be used as SQ3R – Survey, Question, Read, Recite, Review - from Robinson, Francis Pleasant, (1961, 1970) Effective study (4th ed.), Harper & Row, New York, NY. READ – Read, Evaluate, Ask Questions, Determine VCR3 – Visualizing, Concentrating, Relating, Repeating, Reviewing 180 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities GROUP ACTIVITIES TO END A COURSE 181 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Write Course Questions Purpose: To clarify and solidify learning for the participants. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Ask for Questions (this could be assigned for out of class) Write three questions about the course content Individual 20 min Guide activity Refine questions Triads 10 min Collect questions Debrief activity Hand in questions Discuss aids to process Whole group Activity – Write Course Questions Organizer: Now that the course is coming to an end, what did you learn? Objective: Write and refine questions about the course content. Time: 40 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Personal experience from the class. Monitor and support participation and the exchange of ideas. Process: Individually:  Write three questions that fairly assess the course content. In groups of three:  Share the individual questions.  Refine all questions. Group Success: Everyone in the group has given feedback for revisions. Accountability: Hand in the refined versions of the questions. Debrief: How did writing and refining questions review and strengthen your understanding of the course content? 182 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Write a Legacy Letter Purpose: To leave a legacy for the next group in the course. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 15 min Pose question Guide activity Discuss information that would be useful to know Small groups, envelopes 5 min Collect letters Debrief activity Write a one page letter Discuss aids to process Whole group Activity – Write a Legacy Letter Organizer: course? Have you ever said: “I wish I’d have known about that,” concerning a part of the Objective: To leave a legacy for the next group in the course. Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: exchange of ideas. Process: Paper, and envelopes. Monitor and support participation and the In groups of three or four:  Discuss what would have been helpful to know about the course when you first started. Individually:  Write a short letter (one page) to a new student in the next course giving them helpful tips.  Seal the letter and hand it in. Group Success: Everyone in the group has written a letter. Accountability: Debrief: Each person hands in their letter. How did we help each other in this course? The instructor will hand out the legacy letters at the beginning of the next course. 183 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Exchange Success Tips Purpose: To exchange tips on being successful in class. Time Instructor Activities Learner Activities Techniques / Equipment 10 min Pose question Guide activity Identify things that helped or didn’t help you to succeed Small groups 10 min Collect Success tips Debrief activity Supply Success Tips Discuss aids to process Whole group, flipchart Activity – Exchange Success Tips Organizer: Think back over how you studied for this class. Objective: Describe things that you found helped you and allowed you to succeed. Also describe things that were not helpful. Time: 20 minutes Techniques / Equipment: Personal experiences. Flipchart, and felt pens. Monitor and support participation and the exchange of ideas. Process: In small groups of three or four:  Discuss things that helped or didn’t help you to succeed. In the whole group:  Share your tips. Group Success: Everyone in the group has identified success tips. Accountability: Share one tip with the whole group. Debrief: How do we celebrate our success? 184 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities DEBRIEFING FOR GROUP PROCESSING                         How does the support of others assist your learning? What were the differences that arose over using some phrases or concepts? How did you manage them? Identify how constructive communication assists in completing tasks. What benefit can you see from being aware of the stages of group process? What was one strategy that you could use right away? How do we celebrate our success? How do we celebrate our completion? How did this approach work for you in dealing with a large amount of material? How do you feel about the responses that were used? Which responses that have been generated could you see yourself using? Identify what you can offer to your group to move the project forward. Discuss the most frustrating aspect of the activity/exercise. How do the other identified alternatives change your point of view? In what ways did the discussion of comparisons clarify the material? How did the information from other members of the group expand your knowledge of the applications available. How easy would it be for these situations to occur? Could you imagine yourself in one? What thoughts did other people in your group share that expanded your understanding of these situations? Identify how the comments of others assisted the final version. What did we learn from doing ours and looking at other’s versions? How did the information from other members of the group expand your understanding of the applications available? What points were brought out in the discussion that helped to focus your thoughts? How could you adapt your messages for better communications? How did your group members add to your knowledge? How do the individual statements of understanding match the context presented in class? What ideas came up that you hadn’t thought of yourself? What other connections can be made with the synthesized information and other similar situations? 185 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities  How have the opinions of others affected your views?   How easy would it be to miss vital information? Could you imagine doing this if you did not have a form? What suggestions did other people share that added to the final form? How did your partner’s observations differ from your own? In what way was this helpful to your understanding of the site? Identify ways that your group members assisted your memory of the functions. What were the challenges to be dealt with to complete the report within the time frame? What parts of the process are clear? What parts still need more explanation? What were the easiest terms to learn? What were the hardest terms to learn? What made a difference? What insights did your partner share that clarified any part of the presentation for you?  Are there goals that have been shared that could also fit into your goals?         How did the explanations of others and your questions assist in understanding the material? How did it feel to take on the different roles? What made it easy? What made it harder? How did the explanations of others and your questions assist in understanding the material? How did other people’s points help you to develop your concepts? How did we work well together? What were the best sources of information and who located them? How did the group use the information to produce the presentation? What criteria did the group use to decide the best presentation methods? How did you decide? How does what you know compare with what you think that you need to know? What are you doing with this realization? Return notes at the next class with comments and clarification. Go over the main points and fill in missing elements. How did your team help support you and prepare you for answering? How do you feel about your performance? How much of what you ended up with on your list was due ideas of others? Was this an effective means of covering this material for you? Why or why not? What might have been done to increase overall commitment to the group decision?                  What did you learn? How did your small group and the larger group assist your learning? What was your reaction when told initially what was required of you? How do you feel about it now? How do you and your group feel about the material as presented? How did time pressure affect your performance? What feelings arise from reflecting on the effect of this information on your actions and the actions of others? 186 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities    How would you compare the feelings in your group about this to someone with a professional involvement, such as . How well do you think that your group can meet the requirements of this assignment? What were the challenges to be dealt with to complete the essay/tape/project/etc.? What happened with respect to your perception of through the discussion? What was the greatest help that your group members rendered in completing the task? Identify how discussing the situation added to how well you could identify your feelings about the situation. Identify how sharing information added to how well you know the material. Identify how the observation and feedback from your partner assisted your practise.  What was the best part of your practise with your partners?      187 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities DEBRIEFING FOR IDEA PROCESSING                          Compare predictions with actual results. What surprises or confirmations do you see? What elements of other diagrams made the sequence clearer to you? How does discussing “worst case scenarios” change your perception of what might happen and what you might do about it? What elements of information have you added to your list? How did this approach work for you in dealing with a large amount of material? How does a clear criteria affect the way that you will approach this project/exercise? Reflect on the process of identifying essential elements. This framework will be used to reflect on specific incidents. In what ways did linking information to the model clarify the material? What is one goal that you can start on immediately? How does the rationale match current reality? How could you employ the concept in a new situation or to a new problem? What did you learn or change your mind about through the process of analyzing the material? What was it that had the most impact on that learning or change? What did you see that you haven’t seen or looked at before? How did you feel in a role that is different from your usual role? What questions does this discussion leave you with? What questions still remain about this concept? What will help you to better assign priority to a incident? Where and when could this application be useful? Why might you recommend one process be used in preference to another? Reflect on the difficulties of . What do you think about the responses that were used? Which responses that have been generated could you see yourself using? How would you react to these situations in the past? Now? How does this discussion affect your personal mindset? What was the biggest difficulty with the way your group sequenced the information gathering? In what type of situation would this be problematic? Reflect on the importance of in the context of the other materials. 188 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities           Which step do you have the best understanding of at this time? Which step are you least clear about? What element of the process is clearer to you now? How will you make use of this application? What resources will you need to apply these strategies? What information did you learn within this process about your partner or others in the class? Next session, go over the main points and fill in missing elements. Identify strengths and areas for improvement. What connections between have been clarified for you? What were the differences that you saw in how your pair and other pairs searched for references? How did this affect the length of the compiled list? How did writing and refining questions review and strengthen your understanding of the course content? 189 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities REFERENCES Angelo, Thomas A. & Cross, K. Patricia (1993) Classroom Assessment Techniques: A Handbook for College Teachers Interaction Book Company, 7208 Cornelia Drive, Edina, MN 55435 Armstrong, Thomas. (1994) Multiple Intelligences in the classroom, Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development; Alexandria, VA. Aronson, E., Blaney, N., Stephan, C., Sikes, J., & Snap, M. (1978) The jigsaw classroom. Sage, Beverly Hills, California, USA. Bondwell, C.C. & Eison, J. A. (1991) Active Learning: Creating Excitement in the Classroom. ASHE - ERIC Higher Education Reports. Bossert, S. T. (1988-1989). Cooperative activities in the classroom. Review of Research in Education, 15, 225-252. Brooks, J.G. & Brooks, M.G. (1993) In Search of Understanding: The Case for Constructivist Classrooms, Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development; Alexandria, VA. Cohen, E. G. (1994b). Restructuring the classroom: Conditions for productive small groups. Review of Educational Research, 64, 1-35. Jacob, E. (1999). Cooperative Learning in Context. State University of New York Press, Albany, NY, USA. Johnson, David, & Johnson, Roger W. (1989) Cooperation and Competition: Theory and Research Interaction Book Co, 7208 Cornelia Drive, Edina, MN 55435. Johnson, David, & Johnson, Roger W. (1990) Learning Together and Alone. Interaction Book Co, 7208 Cornelia Drive, Edina, MN 55435. Johnson, David, & Johnson, Roger W., & Holubec, Edythe (1992) Advanced Cooperative Learning (revised), Interaction Book Company; 7208 Cornelia Drive, Edina, MN 55435. Johnson, David, & Johnson, Roger W., & Holubec, Edythe (1993) Cooperation in the Classroom, Interaction Book Company; 7208 Cornelia Drive, Edina, MN 55435. Johnson, David, & Johnson, Roger W., & Smith, Karl. (1991) Active Learning: Cooperation in the College Classroom; Interaction Book Company, 7208 Cornelia Drive, Edina, MN 55435, ISBN 0-939603-14-4 Kagen, Spencer. (1994) Cooperative Learning, Resources for Teachers. 27128 Paseao Espada, Suite 622, San Juan Capistrano, CA, 92675, ISBN 1-879097-10-9 Karre, Idatlynn (1994) Busy, Noisy and Powerfully Effective: Cooperative Learning Tools in the College Classroom. Department of Speech Communication, University of Northern Colorado, Greeley, CO, 80639. 190 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities Kohn, Alfie (1986) No Contest: The Case Against Competition. Houghton Mifflin Company. Munns, William Edward. (1992) Effective Group Participation: Using Leadership Role Cards. Will I Am Books, P.O. Box 27624, Seattle, WA, 98125 Parker, John F. (1990) Workshops for Active Learning; JPF Productions; Delta, BC. Scholtes, P. R. (1988). The team handbook: How to use teams effectively. Madison, WI: Joiner Associates, Inc. ISBN 0-9622264-0-8 Sharan, S. (1980). Cooperative learning in small groups: Recent methods and effects on achievement, attitudes and ethnic relations. Review of Educational Research, 50, 241-271. Slavin, Robert E. (1990) Cooperative Learning: Theory, Research, and Practice. Allyn and Bacon, Toronto, ISBN 0-13-172594-7 Tiberius, Richard G. (1990) Small Group Teaching: a Trouble-Shooting Guide ISBN 0-77440344-6 Williams, Bruce More than 50 Ways to Build Team Consensus (1993) ITI/Skylight Publishing, Palestine, IL Wlodkowski, Raymond J. (1989) Enhancing Adult Motivation to Learn Jossey-Bass Publishers, San Francisco, CA. 191 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities COOPERATIVE LEARNING INTERNET BASED RESOURCES Sheridan College website on cooperative learning in the college http://www-acad.sheridanc.on.ca/scls/coop/cooplrn.htm US Government report on cooperative learning http://www.ed.gov/pubs/OR/ConsumerGuides/cooplear.html Group Work and Collaborative Learning at Ryerson http://www.ryerson.ca/lt/resources/teaching_techniques/group_work.html Learning & Teaching: group work guide for staff and students (University of Sydney, Australia) http://sydney.edu.au/education_social_work/groupwork/index.shtml University of Guelph Teaching Support Services information on Cooperative/Collaborative Learning http://www.uoguelph.ca/tss/resources/onlineres/coopcollab-learning.htm Website with information on Jigsaw groups http://www.jigsaw.org/ Southwest Consortium for the *Improvement of Mathematics and Science Teaching: Cooperative Learning http://www.sedl.org/pubs/classroom-compass/cc_v1n2.pdf K-12 materials by Spencer Kagan http://www.kaganonline.com/free_articles/ A web site with just about everything by Ted Panitz http://home.capecod.net/~tpanitz/ Richard Felder on Cooperative Learning http://www4.ncsu.edu/unity/lockers/users/f/felder/public/Papers/CLChapter.pdf http://www4.ncsu.edu/unity/lockers/users/f/felder/public/Papers/CLStrategies%28JCCCT%29.pd f ERIC Higher Education Digests on Active and Cooperative Learning http://ntlf.com/html/lib/bib/digests.htm 192 Cooperative Learning Structures and Activities INDEX academic controversy, 140 define, 75 Pass A Problem, 103 active listening, 50, 52, 54 develop, 127, 128 perception checking, 55 analysis, 102, 106, 107, 108, difference, 134 plan, 91, 170, 171 109, 111, 112, 113, 114, 123, endings, 181 practise, 146, 148 126, 128, 132, 135, 136, 161 equipment operation, 98 presentation, 172 analyze, 93 evaluate, 142 prioritize, 138 application, 100, 132, 144 evaluation, 128 problem solving, 92 assess, 120 exercise, 171 procedure, 78 assessment, 162 feedback, 45, 47, 174, 175 process, 78, 125, 127, 132 audit, 126 flow charting, 90 processing, group, 185 benefits, 132 form groups, 30, 33 processing, idea, 188 block diagram, 89 functions, 130 quality, 58 case studies, 136, 137 goal setting, 34 recommend, 120 change, 155 goals, 29 referrals, 166 characteristics, 81 graph, 115, 116 reflection, 154, 155 citation, 164 group closure, 41 report, 85, 86, 161 clarify, 139 group formation, 21 research, 164, 177 classbuilder, 37, 39 group processing, 35 resources, 163 classification, 93 history, 79 response, 110, 155 classify, 107 improvement plan, 58 review, 84, 167 climate setting, 21 incidents, 95 scenarios, 97 coaching, 64 individual accountability, 62, 63 self analysis, 54 communication, 27 interaction, 145 share, 36 communication strategies, 44 interview, 168 structures, 17 compare, 105, 122, 123, 124, issues, 133 summarize, 165, 179 knowledge, 81 supports and limits, 123 completion, 80 limit assumptions, 55 synthesis, 128, 141 comprehension, 82 link, 129 systems, 105, 124 conduct, 126 map reading, 88 team assessment, 58 conflict management, 60 memorize, 76 template, 18 creativity, 131, 141 negotiating compromise, 60 timelines, 96 critical thinking, 58, 159 observation, 152 trust, 31, 34, 74 debrief, 185, 188 paraphrasing, 49 visualization, 77 125 193